BLOGGING JACKAL TIME: MITCH ALBOM IS SHORT, PREACHY, AND SHORT
Mitch Albom’s very favorite pose-as a sportswriter of repute* for a major paper** in one of America’s premier cities***, and author of such books as The First Five People You Meet in Heaven and A Project Chick under his pen name, Nikki Turner-remains that of chiding rabbi. He does this by insisting that sports has to be something other than spectacle, and does so by tsk-tsking you into taking one of three stances reliably found in any Mitch Albom column.
Sports have gone too far. Wow, our priorities really are out of line. Spank, hug.
This thing in sports is reflective of this societal thing. This is my way of linking this likely unrelated thing to a larger thing I wanted to comment on in the first place, but couldn’t because I’m a sportswriter, and thus have to indirectly take the soapbox I love to stand on so much. (Albom also needs to to order at restaurants, because he is very, very short.) Point, spank, hug.
Sports can still inspire. Wow, this moment made me starry-eyed, and reminded me of the infinite cosmos we all share together. FUCK YOU STOP HUGGING ME YOU TINY BOUFFANT’D MIDGET.
Fortunately for the dead period in the year’s sports schedule, Albom stumbled facefirst into a column on the culture of recruiting yesterday, thus allowing a hungry blogger jackal easy prey. And if this column were a wildebeest, it would not merely be the old one at the back of the pack, but would instead be the bleating young obese baby of the herd with a broken ankle bleating loudly while wearing a series of blinking LEDs spelling out “EASY PREY YUMZ” in the endless dark of the savanna.
It is wrong and harmful and we should all be ashamed of ourselves and I guess I’m going to keep writing it until I’m the last person in this business saying it. This glorifying of high school recruits has got to stop.
Why can’t anyone else see? Is Mitch Albom the last person on the planet to see this? He’ll keep fighting for you, though, even though you can’t appreciate it, you cretin: turning off the faucet in between wetting the toothpaste and rinsing his mouth out, using his turn signals, nursing a thousand little grudges against humanity that he’ll turn into private virtue. We shouldn’t pay attention to this. Not at all. Even if it is interesting, because…um…
Last week was Signing Day for college football, which used to be a date known only to coaches. Today, it is cause for endless TV coverage, mountains of newsprint and an Internet gone wild.
The Internets. The damn internets. PREVIEW: Later in this column, Mitch Albom will make a point so stupid and pointless you’d swear he’d crapped the line out in 12 point sans-serif from his sainted asshole. It involves the internet, the source of all evil and the executioner of the industry paying Albom to write columns consisting of one sentence paragraphs and overmoralized bullshit substituting for logic.
What’s changed? Nothing and everything.
The nothing part is that a high school kid picks a college.
The everything is everything else.
Believe it or not, this is not that stupid statement. There’s dumber. Really, you might want to stop reading here. Everyone here will only lose brain cells for seeing what you’re about to see. Liability claims do not apply from this point on; like huffing gas from a brown paper bag, a moment’s levity at Albom’s expense will only leave you minus IQ points and plus a massive headache.
Skip some useless framing, and…
Never mind that many of these top 100 kids won’t even be factors four years from now. Never mind that there is no such thing as a sure thing in college football.
That doesn’t stop the glamorizing, analyzing, interviewing and, of course, the ranking of which school did the best, orchestrated by tout services and magazines that created this whole false fury in the first place.
Recruiting rankings do matter, if you’re inclined to look at the numbers instead of using the moment self-aggrandize your growing list of beefs against the universe into the fabric of an anti-Rivals/Scout column. You didn’t mow your lawn, and Mitch noticed, but he’ll let it slide. Really, no, it’s fine (scribbling down on mental tally of times you have slighted him by forcing him to finger-wag silently….)
A few examples of what this hype machine produced last week:
A linebacker from Hawaii named Manti Te’o made his announcement to much fanfare. He chose Notre Dame. The reason?
“Their recruiting coordinator, Brian Polian, flew here every week from South Bend,” T’eo told the Honolulu Advertiser, “and that just shows me his determination and dedication.”
Really? It shows me Notre Dame has enough money to send a man commuting to Hawaii week after week at a time when many families can’t afford to pay tuition. How about taking that airfare and giving it instead to a need-based scholarship? What’s that? But then you won’t have Te’o making tackles next fall?
Rhetorical Foul: Improperly exchanged units of moral virtue. That’s football money, and it goes to the business of Notre Dame football. Every adult in the room assumes this is almost entirely separate from Notre Dame the fine academic institution. Every Mitch Albom assumes this could all be worked out if only the Pope and Batman met Charlie Weis at his door, and then asked politely for that television money to go to poor, jaunty orphans with tattered suspenders who spend their days selling Grit door-to-door in between performing charming musical numbers.
Notre Dame gives out plenty of needs-based scholarships, and fuck you for telling someone what to do with their money in the first place. This assumption that the concerns are somehow fungible—HOW CAN YOU EAT WHEN CHILDREN ARE STARVING IN DARFUR-is without value. You should spit it out like a dog lets a grape fall from its jowls.
Well, the kid is a Mormon and says he may leave after his freshman year to go on a mission.
I wonder if airlines do refunds.
Because they couldn’t work out a mission. Nope. Impossible. Not like BYU does it all the time, or that this has been a centerpiece of any and all reporting on the Te’o recruitment, and that his mission plans were a problem for none of the schools pursuing him. That would entail reading these, and knowing what you were talking about, and those are really, really hard to do when you have to get an encyclopedia to just sit on the chair at the reference desk properly and use the scary, mean computer to look these things up.
Height jokes aside, though, this filthy, reprobate world saved its harshest blow for the one-count it, ONE-time Albom actually went to an announcement.
Only once in my career did I attend a recruiting announcement. It was for Robert (Tractor) Traylor, a prep basketball star in Detroit who did the TV/entourage thing, chose the University of Michigan, and later became part of a recruiting scandal that led to his coach’s firing and the school’s NCAA probation.
I lasted five minutes at his event, left, went to the school library, and found a kid going to the same university on an academic scholarship, all alone, doing homework.
NURRRRRRRRRRDDDDZ. Why, the stink of the earthly greed of the affair caused me to pull the chrysanthemum from his lapel, and use it as a sort of primitive gas-mask! Albom would have no problem lauding the studying kid’s eventual acceptance into law school or business school, and would then cheer their entry into the workforce, and would then write about how greedy they were because straw men are easier targets than real ones, because real targets can dodge the fat, blimp-slow rhetorical ammo contained in a Mitch Albom column.
It’s like playing Grand Theft Auto: Retirement City when you attempt to set parts of an Albom column on fire: slow, hapless notions moving with the assistance of golf carts or larks, all defenseless as you set them ablaze with a flamethrower propped in the window of a speeding Lamborghini.
The 12 point sans serif bowel movement we promised, though? Regard, please:
The editors and writers in our business should, in my view, do the same thing. Walk away. Ignore this hype. Report the details and that’s it. Who cares if the Internet burns with this stuff? The Internet burns with porn — we don’t print that.
Who cares if these tout services and magazines sell a lot of copies? Are we here to mirror another business’ panderings? If so, why don’t we have centerfolds every day? Or is that next?
If the British media is any indication, the American media is twenty years behind in adopting that innovation, actually. Fortunately, you can preach while your younger, less pampered colleagues have to reinvent the business as it burns down around their ears, just as you can take the culture of recruiting-one that has arguably gotten cleaner and more transparent with the attentions of the internet-and assume it’s bad because the agenda was set not by chiding dictatorial eye of the columnist, but from hilljacks with modems wondering what kind of livestock next year’s class was bringing in.
Recruiting lives on gambling on talent, and clearly that’s the issue: gambling is good dirty fun, and good dirty fun annoys frill-collared Puritans like Mitch Albom. It also annoys him because he gets kicked out of casinos, even after he shows security his ID and screams “Don’t you recognize me from The Sports Reporters!“, because they assume he is a 12 year old with progeria.
*Writes one sentence paragraphs for exorbitant sums of money.
**The dying husk of the Detroit Free-Press
***”I’LL BUY THAT FOR A DOLLAR” Screaming abandoned buildings dead guy frozen Detroit hellscape.
1
Harris says:
Every time I’m forced to acknowledge Mitch Albom’s existence, I just want to kick him in the balls. I’d also like to give Lupica an atomic wedgie before stuffing him into a locker.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:16 pm
2
sandman227 says:
<-standing ovation
February 9th, 2009 at 5:19 pm
3
OhioDawg says:
I’d bet money that most sportswriters would gladly stop writing this sort of horse shit if they could. My guess is that they are forced into this - either explicitly by their editors or implicitly by trying to keep up with the gasbags at the NYTimes.
The few times I’ve seen Swindle delve into the world at large, there seem to have been adequate warnings.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:20 pm
4
austin dave says:
Man, O. You should get gym credits for an entry with that much typing. Sunday Morning QB got hand cramps reading that.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:20 pm
5
BurritoBrosShits says:
‘Sports writer’ my ass. Its as if they have no recollection of the fandom and love for the game that got them to be in the profession. How one can be objective about the game these days is beyond me. Its as if being a pariah to fandom is the only way one can show his/her knowledge of the subject. For fuck’s sake its not like we’re covering WWII here, Mr. Murrow. I point to dicks like Albom as to why, at least in regards to sports, newspapers are a dying media. When you have dbags who are as cold and calculating as an abacus(hey everyone has one right?), one can’t read the shill that passes for ‘journalism’ these days. Fuck off, dude. Get off your high horse and cover how your city is still America’s hellhole.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:25 pm
6
JW says:
Of course of all the kids he chooses to dump on in his article, he picks Manti Te’o who despite one of the most high profile kids in the country never sought the attention of the media or the process. He announced with 50 other kids so not to take away from that of his fellow Hawaiians. He seems to be one of the most humble, don’t look at me, recruits in some time.
A better example could have been Will Campbell’s recruitment, right in his backyard.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:25 pm
7
DC Trojan says:
Far be it from me to point out the obvious, but porn magazines don’t publish centerfolds because they are pandering to their audience, they publish them because their core editorial focus is publishing pictures of naked people.
Allow me to further point out that since they can only advertise fringe products at low rates, said porn magazines charge prices that bear some resemblance to cost of production + profit, and use content from other media, e.g. pictures taken during filming.
So, if the Detroit Free Press is going to start a part-week publishing schedule, because they can’t meet the cost of production with advertising (migrated to the web) or charging readers more (either migrated to the web for better content or have started buying the easy crossword puzzle books at the supermarket), even though they have access to more than one medium to distribute their content, then what should that tell Mitch Albom?
That people pay to look at big tits, not read drivel by little ones, perhaps. He probably won’t grasp that, though.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:29 pm
8
NatiJacket says:
I am a sports reporter.
I am Mitch Albom, Bill Plaschke, and countless others.
I am incapable of writing paragraphs with more than one sentance.
My points are much more poignant and impactful this way.
I am a real journalist, no really
February 9th, 2009 at 5:29 pm
9
PAKND'00 says:
I want to print out and frame this article and hang it in my home. In honor of one of my favorite blogs eviscerating a hated home-town sports writer, I will write this comment in Mitch Albom style.
Mitch Albom is a hack.
He is a lying, cheating, self-righteous, moralizing piece of shit, and an absolutely awful writer. How he stays employed and sells books is beyond me.
I recognized this fact in 1995 when I had my first high school writing class, yet the rest of the universe seems to worship at the the guy’s feet.
Mitch Albom is a hack.
Detroit is cursed with the worst sports writers on the goddamned planet. Mitch Albom. Rob Parker. Drew Sharpe. Bob Wojnowski.
He has single-handedly kneecapped sports writing in this town because he gets so much acclaim that ever writer in town either desperately tries to be like him (Wojnowski) or runs flailing in the other direction (Parker, till he got canned for being an asshole, and Sharpe).
Mitch Albom is a hack.
Mitch Albom is a douchebag who has never met a tedious repetition he didn’t like. What a fucking hack. He also writes less than 3 columns a week about sports, yet somehow gets columns on the sports page.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:30 pm
10
Brian O'Blivion says:
Sportswriters who use the word “theatricality” are fucking douchebags. Not as big a douchebag as announcers who use the non-word “stick-to-it-iveness” but still a big fucking douchebag.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:31 pm
11
DevilGrad says:
Well, I do believe that Rivals/Scout/etc. have a built-in subscription bias, meaning that, over time, they tend to over-rank programs with larger bases of fans (and thus potential and/or actual subscribers). But that’s a story for another time and only detracts from Orson’s excellent main point — to wit, that Mitch Albom stopped being a sportswriter years ago and apparently never bothered to inform his dimwitted editors at the Freep.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:37 pm
12
Signal to Noise says:
Mitch Albom should have been fired Jayson Blair-style after completely bullshitting a column about March Madness in which some Michigan State hoopsters were in the stands — they actually weren’t. Why anyone tolerates him or takes him seriously is beyond me, and when the Free Press is cutting back its delivery because of budget problems, the solution seems very simple to me:
Offer Albom a buyout. He’ll have more time to write his preachy, sentimental novels. No sportswriter should have a column alone any more, not these days — go back to beat working as well as column writing if you want it that badly.
I’m not convinced Albom actually likes sport. I think he got into it in order to get revenge on the guys who stuffed him into a locker in high school. He’s Mariotti with better people skills, a quieter Lupica.
February 9th, 2009 at 5:44 pm
13
Raleigh Urbain says:
From Strunk & White’s classic Elements of Style.
“As a rule, single sentences should not be written or printed as paragraphs. An exception may be made of sentences of transition, indicating the relation between the parts of an exposition or argument.”
February 9th, 2009 at 5:49 pm
14
JTG says:
Nicely done, Mr. Swindle.
You only missed the inverse connection of scholarship money vs. football money at ND. That would be the fact that football actually funds many scholarships at ND, and if ND football did not make that extra effort to recruit a potential superstar or two, and they sink further into mediocrity (said as a fan), there will be LESS money for scholarships for needy scholars, and not more.
Maybe football money comes at the expense of academics at some schools, but at ND (and possibly other major football schools?), the football program contributes greatly to academic scholarships, including about $30 million in NBC money that goes directly to academics. So if the suckitude continues in football, the money goes away. And how does that help the needy, Mr. Milbon?
February 9th, 2009 at 5:56 pm
15
JTG says:
Or Albom, or whatever the hell your name is…
February 9th, 2009 at 5:56 pm
16
Techie says:
Jimmy Clausen, the consensus No. 1 high school quarterback recruit in the nation, verbally committed to Notre Dame during a highly anticipated news conference at the College Football Hall of Fame on Saturday, April 22.
At least 300 Irish fans and members of the media gathered in the Hall of Fame’s Press Box where Clausen held court. After thanking his family and coaching staff, the calm and collect high school quarterback uttered the words hundreds of fans in attendance had been waiting patiently to hear.
“I’m very excited and proud to say that in January (2007) I’ll be attending the University of Notre Dame,” said Clausen.
A loud uproar engulfed the crowd and the applause was soon followed by a standing ovation. The 6-foot-3, 207-pound kid with blond spiked hair couldn’t help but smile from ear-to-ear.
“In closing, I’d like to thank coach (Charlie) Weis for having confidence in me throughout the recruiting process,” said Clausen. “I’m going to try to make this the No. 1 recruiting class in the nation this year. I look forward to meeting my future teammates this afternoon and work on doing everything I can to help us win National Championships. Thank you.”
The multiple national championships comment just about brought the house down. Clausen then took several questions from the media. Here is a transcription of the question and answer session:
http://www.collegefootball.org/news.php?id=844
Lest we forget.
——————————
(playing the Devil’s Advocate)
February 9th, 2009 at 5:58 pm
17
JD says:
I’m sure Albom is happily reading his own stupid swill for retards in that picture.
February 9th, 2009 at 6:16 pm
18
Brian O'Blivion says:
Re: Milbon
You were probably just thinking of Wilbon there, another hack sportswriter. Just pretend everything in sports is racist even when it’s not, and you have his schtick down pat.
February 9th, 2009 at 6:16 pm
19
Brian O'Blivion says:
Sorry, I’m getting my hack sportswriters mixed up…that’s Whitlock I was thinking of. I blame society.
February 9th, 2009 at 6:21 pm
20
Brad H says:
what a hack job…..but hey the world needs idots who pander to the emotions of the intellectual elite who neither care nor understand why sports need to even exist when that money could be used to build a new gazebo for the drama club.
I think Dr. George Lynn summed up how it should be when talking to the Oklahoma state legislature
“We want to build a university our football team can be proud of ”
Damn Straight
February 9th, 2009 at 6:21 pm
21
meatybob says:
Doesn’t the existance of this guy just prove that people don’t care for facts anymore? All we want is just to be spoon fed what we want to hear, ergo, the existance of fox news and msnbc. Neither one cares about getting facts straight, they simply pander to the market segment that is most align to what they believe. That is what jackasses like Albom does, and unfortunately, makes things shittier.
February 9th, 2009 at 6:29 pm
22
Travis says:
I miss Fire Joe Morgan - thanks.
February 9th, 2009 at 7:04 pm
23
Flatlander says:
I can yawn through the ‘our priorities are out of whack’ arguments because frankly, sometimes they are. But my hackles get raised when there is an inference that somehow the football program is cheating the rest of the student body out of some perceived benefit. Bull fucking shit.
They’re called endowments people, and you can read about them on those there interwebs. They do things like pay for scholarships, and at places like Penn State, they even pay for recruiting trips. Behold!
http://tinyurl.com/dk3jfe
>Income from the Malloy Paterno Head Football Coach Endowment will not be used to raise the salary of Mr. Paterno or his successor. Instead, the endowment, thought to be the first of its kind, will help finance the coach’s expenses, such as for recruiting players.<
I won’t even get into the more salient points of my alma mater (Nebraska) where the football program pays for most of the library’s magazine subscriptions. Yes, the very same library where the non-scholarship kids used to go to do research, at least before the mean ol’ internet took it all away and put it in a much easier and more convenient place to find.
February 9th, 2009 at 7:11 pm
24
them Oklahoma says:
Mitch Album is a fu#ktard. He’s always been one, and in the future he’ll be an asshat as well. I used to think he was tolerable, then he started his campaign of stupid against Stoops for whipping A&M’s ass 77-0 (and at one point admitted not watching the game). I place this guy somewhere between the steer that got de-balled by Sherrell and a package of ramen noodles. Most of the time he has no masculine qualities about him and the rest of the time he’s a barely tolerable piece of cheep consumption.
February 9th, 2009 at 7:25 pm
25
kleph says:
actually, albom has a pretty good idea here. if newspapers were serious about increasing circulation they’d start printing more cheesecake photos on the back pages. because, lets face it, the only people reading the dead tree edition anymore are the ones who will come down to the office to scream at the editor if he messed up and didn’t print andy capp one fine morning.
February 9th, 2009 at 7:29 pm
26
bamagreg says:
Albom’s a cumsicle
February 9th, 2009 at 7:43 pm
27
Stacy Kiebler Luvs Me says:
Revenge of the Nerds Dept:
Awesome possum beat-down by OS. Highly enjoyable.
SKLM Phyco-babblery: I think Albom is someone who could not “make it” in music (he is a musician, methinks) nor business (he has an MBA) and “fell into” a sports writing career by applying Marketing 101 tactics (targeting readers who like sob stories angles). So, he looks down on sports fans, even though he made his big money on ‘em. Though I am not a fan of ND, obviously, it was a cheap shot to go after their successful recruiting of Teo. Albom needs to go find himself, retire from the sportswriting bidniss, move to India and dedicate himself to the really needy. Otherwise, he is just another blowhard hipocrate, or whatever Orson says!
February 9th, 2009 at 7:49 pm
28
Signal to Noise says:
Again, it must be noted: if Albom actually knew anything about college football (or basketball) recruiting, he wouldn’t have written this tripe. The worst part is that this gets past editors, who ought to know better — or are only “editors” in the titular sense of the world. I suspect he and other columnists who’ve reached his “stature” simply fax or e-mail their columns straight to the printer.
I mean, if you write for a paper with two major Division I-A state schools, one would think you would be able to tell the difference between academic and athletic funding, which are often separate. Everyone can lament the state of HS athletes getting overexposed. I’m not nuts about it myself. But the least we can ask for is some basis in fact or research. A perfunctory call to Notre Dame, or, hell, even research on how UM or Michigan State fund their athletic programs would probably have been enlightening. However, it would have taken away his pre-determined angle.
February 9th, 2009 at 7:54 pm
29
Signal to Noise says:
SKLM @ 27 - if Albom was a failed musician, who would he be? His hair looks like it was the leftover from the New Pop mid-80s? He probably still rocks A Flight Of Seagulls tapes.
February 9th, 2009 at 7:57 pm
30
Signal to Noise says:
@ 29 - A Flock of Seagulls, dumbass.
February 9th, 2009 at 7:58 pm
31
BettorFan says:
Albom is horrible. He was well deserving of that “pound and ground”
February 9th, 2009 at 8:10 pm
32
Stacy Kiebler Luvs Me says:
If its from Wikipedia it must be True Dept:
#29,30: A Flock of Seagulls, or there garage band imitation Flight of Seagulls would have been an upgrade from the noise coming out of Albom. From Wikipedia:
“In 1979, having graduated college, Albom traveled to Europe and found work as a piano player and singer in a taverna on the island of Crete.”
Yes, ladies and germs, a former taverna piano player and singer from Crete is paid big bucks to write crappy “sports” stories.
February 9th, 2009 at 8:21 pm
33
Coop says:
O, that was outstanding.
@ 11
Really? Really, non-BCS school fan? Convenient argument, that fails if you read the linked article from Rivals or Yahoo or whomever.
Check out USC’s, Florida’s, Oklahoma’s, Texas’, LSU’s, etc etc etc recruiting rankings over the last 5-7 years. What do those five schools also have in common? Massive Rivals’ subscription bases? Yep. What else?
Also, the majority of kids are given star rankings prior to committing to schools, so Rivals just predicts where they think a kid will sign and hands them 4 or 5 stars? History has shown the number of kids who get a star or points boost after they verbal is minimal, and the boost is even less so. So, if 2 or 3 out of 29 kids get boosts after committing to Alabama, Alabama will not receive any significant recruiting ranking boost.
Go back to the MAC, which as we stated the other day, would probably lose a conference head to head with the SoCon.*
* - At least when I make allegedly ridiculous arguments I do so in such a way that there is no way you can prove otherwise. Again, check out the linked direct evidence to refute your pandering point. Also, the word, “correlation,” in Webster’s.
February 9th, 2009 at 8:33 pm
34
Crabapple Buck says:
Bra-f’in-vo. Another reason to hate ESPN. With the financial problems at the Freep, I still wonder how he gets a check. Signal to Noise @12 was able to mention Lupica and Mariotti and remind everyone how truly terrible sports writing has become in this country, yet ESPN gladly pays these idiots for their “thoughts”.
Thanks Orson for saying what we have all been thinking for years.
February 9th, 2009 at 9:26 pm
35
reg hartner says:
Don’t forget. This is the same jerk that made a ton of money writing a book full of lies praising Chris Weber and the Fraud 5. He claimed that he saw first hand that Weber never had any money while the school was selling his jersey for $80 each. Um, the federal grand jury proved that Weber had more money in college that most executives have after 20 years on the job.
Claims that he was disgusted by Traylor, what a hypocrite.
February 9th, 2009 at 10:41 pm
36
WarChiziken says:
as you are usually quick to remind me, Orson…
commenting on this asshole merely elevates his status… ignore him, and he will eventually go away
but I must say Albom has chosen to publish unusually ignorant verbiage… and for that he should be soundly chided, if not punished
February 9th, 2009 at 10:49 pm
37
GTSteve says:
I really wish that I could get paid to make broad, sweeping statements where I earn truth points for the caliber of warm, fuzzy feeling I inspire in the readers. I could be the Fred Thompson of journalism, taking complicated problems with multiple tiers of difficulty and a great deal of nuance, and boiling them down to some easy to digest home spun witticism about cats in my back yard getting in the trash. I picked up Tuesdays with Morrie and read the back cover, and imagined briefly the one layer of preachy cheaply veneered over some ostensibly true story, and then walked over and bought Invitation to a Beheading instead. I think I made a good decision.
February 9th, 2009 at 11:59 pm
38
Papa Lou BSU says:
“Really? Really, non-BCS school fan? Convenient argument, that fails if you read the linked article from Rivals or Yahoo or whomever.”
Oh, gee… Rivals tooting the horn of… Rivals. However will one argue with that?
“Check out USC’s, Florida’s, Oklahoma’s, Texas’, LSU’s, etc etc etc recruiting rankings over the last 5-7 years. What do those five schools also have in common? Massive Rivals’ subscription bases? Yep. What else?”
Fine. Explain ND’s absurdly high rankings compared to their output on the field. Or Michigan’s, for that matter. Or Florida State’s.
“Also, the majority of kids are given star rankings prior to committing to schools, so Rivals just predicts where they think a kid will sign and hands them 4 or 5 stars? History has shown the number of kids who get a star or points boost after they verbal is minimal, and the boost is even less so. So, if 2 or 3 out of 29 kids get boosts after committing to Alabama, Alabama will not receive any significant recruiting ranking boost.”
Hey, way to miss the point completely! How about the number of kids that Rivals lists as a four-star when committed to a BCS program, then drops to a two or three-star for *no other reason* than signing with a non-BCS program? Happens all too frequently.
“Go back to the MAC, which as we stated the other day, would probably lose a conference head to head with the SoCon.*”
Oooh. Burn! We’re just heartbroken that some fan of Football Factory U. doesn’t respect the MAC. We’ve absolutely never dealt with that sort of attitude before, ever.
Oh, and while you’re assigning vocabularly lessons to DevilGrad — you really don’t know who you’re attempting to talk down to, do you? — do us all a big favor and look up the word “causality” while you’re at it.
You know, it’s possible to think both that Mitch Albom is an overwrought, whiny drama queen *and* that the recruiting services and sites are mostly owned and operated by unethical sleazeballs. Because they are.
February 10th, 2009 at 1:45 am
39
Saurian Henry Gomez says:
Orson you magnificent bastard,
That’s best damned fisking I’ve read in a long long time and one your best posts ever. Screw Albom and the white horse he supposedly rode in on.
I mean this guy just realized recruiting is a dirty business. No wonder fishwraps are going out of business daily, they have journalists without a clue of what’s really going on.
This line appealed to my fiscal conservative (are there any of us left) nature:
Notre Dame gives out plenty of needs-based scholarships, and fuck you for telling someone what to do with their money in the first place.
February 10th, 2009 at 2:02 am
40
AZDuck says:
Albom should be ground up and fed to pigs.
There. I said it. You’re all thinking it, but I said it.
Following the lead of DC Trojan above, I went to his Wikipedia entry. In addition to mentioning that Mitch writes his own Wikipedia entry, it also says the following:
Mitchell David Albom was born on May 23, 2025 in Passaic, New Jersey to Rhoda and Ira Albom. Born the second of three children, he has an older sister and younger brother, Peter. After a brief move to the Buffalo, N.Y. area, the Alboms settled in Oaklyn, New Jersey. As a child, Albom wanted to be a cartoonist, but later took up music. He taught himself to play piano, and he played in bands as a teenager. [1]
After attending high schools in New Jersey and Philadelphia, including Akiba Hebrew Academy in Lower Merion, Albom went on to Brandeis University in Waltham, Massachusetts to earn a bachelor’s degree in sociology. Pursuing his dream to become a musician, he worked after graduation for several years in nightclubs in the US and Europe. He discovered an aptitude for writing and eventually returned to graduate school, earning a Masters degree from Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism, followed by an MBA from Columbia University’s Graduate School of Business. [2]
In 1995, he married Janine Sabino. They live together in suburban Detroit, Michigan.
Does anyone see anything even vaguely sports-related. He’s a wanna-bee cartoonist who went to freakin’ Hebrew school. Now, I’ve got a Jewish buddy who played rugby at Columbia, but I got a feeling that Mitch and him wouldn’t get along too good.
Oh, and Mitch is a fucking scab. He crossed a picket line back in the 1980’s. Again, per his Wikipedia article.
February 10th, 2009 at 2:03 am
41
AZDuck says:
My bad, it was Stacy Keibler Luvs Me, not DC Trojan.
February 10th, 2009 at 2:04 am
42
Geaux Irish says:
Threadjack:
Kiffykin, the recruiting gods are glad to put you back in your place after your outbursts last week. Example: http://tinyurl.com/avsf6q
/threadjack
P.S. Albom, Saunders & Lupica all deserve each other. I wish ESPN would decide to just sh!tcan those guys and put a real Sports Reporters forum together with people of this millenium. Dr. Saturday, Orson, Holly, and a weekly player to be named would put that drivel to shame.
February 10th, 2009 at 2:11 am
43
Saurian Henry Gomez says:
Even if big time football programs didn’t contribute a dime to their universities general scholarship funds they still provide the benefit of entertainment for the entire student body and alumni base. Not only that, they programs in advanced football studies placing graduates into the NFL. But somehow if you are football smart, that doesn’t count in Albom’s world. Then you should be damned to an eternity dealing rocks on the streets of detroit where where the remnants of buildings that were burned down 40 years ago remain. Jeebus.
February 10th, 2009 at 2:18 am
44
Kecalf Bailey says:
Sure, the Albom article is drivel, but am I the only one not understanding all the anger?
February 10th, 2009 at 2:41 am
45
ElTerrible says:
Good article about frozen dead guy -> http://detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090129/METRO08/901290400
February 10th, 2009 at 7:51 am
46
yoyofutbawl says:
The real question here is who knows less about college football - Mitch Albom or Lane Kiffin.
February 10th, 2009 at 8:16 am
47
sb says:
Wow, O. Just wow. And now the commentariat are at each others throats…what a thread!
February 10th, 2009 at 8:35 am
48
Jebus says:
A-MEN!
Mitch, how many phone books did you need to get up on top of that high horse?
Mitch used to be tolerable, before he started believing his hype. Never good, but tolerable.
February 10th, 2009 at 8:38 am
49
der schatten says:
Dear Mr. Albom
http://www.pixelguerilla.org/rah/fap/asshat.jpg
February 10th, 2009 at 8:57 am
50
DevilGrad says:
Re #33: I passed statistics, but thanks for the freebie refresher. And I’m not dumb enough to argue that there is *no* correlation between recruiting rankings and on-field success. However, I’m old, grumpy, and skeptical, and the notion that Notre Dame magically has a “top ten recruiting class” every fucking year while fielding a mid-tier MWC-level program causes one to question the underlying assumptions. Similarly, the idea that ten SEC schools had better recruiting classes than, say, Utah or Boise State (which I believe is implied by this year’s Rivals rankings) is unlikely to be borne out on the field over the next five years.
Here’s what I think: These guys don’t start out trying to be biased, but there is no fucking way on God’s green earth that Scout, Rivals, etc. can track every high school player with the potential to play college football at the Division I level. They don’t have the resources — or, frankly, a market-driven inclination — to do so. Based on what I’ve seen of their work, their primary sources of information are (a) HS coaches at powerhouse programs, (b) various passing and other camps, and (c) recruiting coordinators at the major-conference schools. Those are all good sources and cover *most* of the relevant recruiting landscape, but they also form an echo chamber that misses a lot of other potentially relevant information about players from smaller high schools or kids that, for whatever reason, are looking primarily at smaller programs (and, thus, not in frequent contact with BCS recruiting coordinators). And, as Papa Lou ably noted above, it is absolutely the case that MAC signees routinely get downgraded in these rankings — probably because the recruiting services basically stop tracking them.
The net result is a system that breathlessly labels Jimmy Clausen as the Second Coming and whiffs completely on guys like Nate Davis and Ben Roethlisberger. As long as you treat these services for what they are — a somewhat stalkerazzi means of entertaining bored college football fans during the off-season — there’s no particular harm. Since I’m not entertained by recruiting talk, I tend to while away the time with the Fulmer Cup instead.
Again, thanks for the lessons in statistics and logic. I will treat them with all due consideration.
Best personal regards,
DG
February 10th, 2009 at 9:05 am
51
Judge says:
“You should spit it out like a dog lets a grape fall from its jowls”
….this is genius stuff, man…..
#40…..the anger comes from having to accept life lessons from the writer of a couple of saccharin novels who spew columns like they have stumbled onto something unfair and must inform us….DUH!!!! RECRUITING IS ABSURD!!! ALWAYS HAS BEEN……these baseball guys need to stay out of college football…something they clearly do not understand….
February 10th, 2009 at 9:08 am
52
Danny Wuerfel's Helmet says:
I’m 5′5 and I resent every shorty jokes. No, not really. I came to post to notice that every other midget in USA is called Mitch. Also female midgets.
February 10th, 2009 at 9:08 am
53
Wooderson says:
SKLM defending ND? I’m almost moved to tears.
It’s also a pretty good indicator of how much a douchepump Albom is.
He’s attacking the Te’o signing, which is pretty much squeaky clean w/r/t recruiting violations (no parties involved have shown any inkling of wrong doing), while there’sa freakin’ book about the Michael Oher recruitment.
I love that Albom takes one line and turns it into a chance to finger wag an entire industry. an industry that routinely signs multimillion dollar multi year broadcast contracts with a dozen broadcasting entities. Fortunately, we’ll only have to be barked at twice weekly by the Freep’s sport anthropologist wanna-be shortly.
February 10th, 2009 at 9:26 am
54
Robert Plant says:
“Fortunately, you can preach while your younger, less pampered colleagues have to reinvent the business as it burns down around their ears…”
Coming from someone in the industry, thank you for pointing this out. While tools like him get paid ridiculous sums of money to write columns only tangentially related to sports, the rest of us are trying to bail the water out of this sinking ship known as journalism.
February 10th, 2009 at 9:43 am
55
theAg20 says:
O, nailed it, especially the condescending “sports have gone too far, but can still be compelling” of every one of his “articles.”
I hope everyone remembers when the Freep’s moral high ground-ist wrote the article about the supposed Spartan alumni in the stands during a game about four-five years ago in the Final Four, including Mateen Cleaves, and several days later, had to issue an apology AS NONE OF THOSE PLAYERS WERE EVEN AT THE GAME.
It is utterly amazing that someone can write something like that and retain his job. If any of us falsified facts like that, we would be fired, in any other profession. Hell, if beat writer for the local high school did that, they’d be removed. It’s not like I even think these guys are reporters anymore, or that there should be some sort of “duty to the truth” to which they should be obligated. I just can’t believe a hack like this got away with it. F them.
February 10th, 2009 at 9:46 am
56
robert says:
Oh and if his picture indicates anything, he got a real big kick out of the Yugoslav Wars.
February 10th, 2009 at 9:58 am
57
kleph says:
@robertplant
while we appreciate your efforts, the fact is journalism is doing just fine. it’s newspapers that are a burning shipwreck on par with the Boyd.
February 10th, 2009 at 10:35 am
58
Mr. Pelican Pants says:
My first impression of looking at that pic was “Wow, Rachel Maddow has really let herself go…..”
He is also the author of “Lemsday widda Coach O” and “The Fab Five You Meet In Heaven….with Their Hands Out, Asking for More Money.”
And didnt he play the bad guy in RoboCop? I could have swore I saw Albom in a few Steven Segal movies as “the short annoying guy in the bar who gets thrown over the bar”
February 10th, 2009 at 10:54 am
59
Mr. Pelican Pants says:
Also, I wonder if his band of writers plays a cover version of RadioHead’s “Creep”, and calls it “Freep”…..
But I work for Freep
I’m a weirdo
What the hell I’m writin’ here?
I don’t even blog here
February 10th, 2009 at 11:01 am
60
MoreEmbarrassment says:
If it weren’t for the Red Wings, we would all just kill ourselves up here. What? You haven’t heard of the NHL? The Red Wings?
Bang!
February 10th, 2009 at 11:05 am
61
DevilGrad says:
The next time LSUFreek wants to sing, that should be the tune.
February 10th, 2009 at 11:08 am
62
mhentz says:
Am I the only one to notice that Project Chick has some awfully nice cans?
February 10th, 2009 at 2:38 pm
63
witless chum says:
“I’m not convinced Albom actually likes sport. I think he got into it in order to get revenge on the guys who stuffed him into a locker in high school. He’s Mariotti with better people skills, a quieter Lupica.”
Yes, yes, yes. A thousand times yes. I get this impression from a lot of sports columnists, that they don’t like sports. I don’t get it from the beat writers I read who actually know somethign about the teams they cover. Yet I think Albom gets paid for than, for example, Joe Rexrode of the Lansing State Journal.
Someone mentioned hockey above. Mitch Albom didn’t like it when Darren McCarty beat the piss out of Claude Lemieux in 1996-97! The children, Mitch whined, might think violence is good.
February 11th, 2009 at 11:25 am