Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Lance Berkman Could Have Torn ACL

THE CFB BUYERS' GUIDE: OFFENSES

Circles_medium

Each week, EDSBS teams with the research and evaluation experts at Consumers Union to compare different aspects of college football and determine which products are most worthy of your hard-earned dollar. We've already tested first-year coaches, Heisman contenders, and BCS-buster prospects; we keep asking our editor when we can road-test sideline reporters, but we think he's figured us out on that one. So instead, this week we bring you a comparison of offensive attacks: Which ones will give you yard after yard of efficient performance, and which ones will break after only a few uses?

 

TOP RATED

Colin_kaepernick_medium
NEVADA | ■ ■ ■ ■ ½

Highs: Unstoppable ground game, minimal noise, versatile on a wide variety of terrain.
Lows: Only so-so through the air, may be too big to fit in your garage.
Don't look know, but the most fascinating offensive show in the country is coming not from Los Angeles or Austin but from Reno, Nevada, where the Wolf Pack is armed with a pistol and mowing down everything that stands in its way. No other product on the market comes with this many features: Multiple thousand-yard rushers in any given season means that if one of them breaks you can just sub in another without missing a beat. The Pack has lived in the shadow of an Idaho-built competitor for a while now, but we think it's ready to stand on its own and begin competing in a higher echelon. Only caveat: Quarterback Colin Kaepernick stands in at an imposing 6'6", so good luck cramming this offense in your garage if you've already got a lot of junk stored in there.

Oregon_medium
OREGON | ■ ■ ■ ■ □

Highs: Best-in-class speed, yet is environmentally friendly.
Lows: May not hold up to repeated use in warmer climates, occasionally punches people.
Intrigued by advertising claims of a "point-a-minute" offense, we purchased a 2010 Oregon model and gave it a workout in the unforgiving desert climate of Arizona. We weren't quite able to recreate those results -- it ended up being more like a point every 85.7 seconds -- but there's still no doubt that this flashy design has what it takes to bring your yard under control an amazingly short amount of time. We're still not 100 percent sure how well it'll hold up in places like, say, Palo Alto or Tucson, and recent Oregon models have not been known for their user-friendliness, but it still looks like the Ducks are one of the better long-term investments in this category.

Star-divide

ABOVE AVERAGE

Stanford-tree_medium
STANFORD | ■ ■ ■ ½ □

Highs: Impressive toughness, clears difficult brush in a hurry.
Lows: Has only faced one actual defense, running back's name is "Stepfan."
We're not accustomed to finding brash design and rugged attitude in a Stanford product, which makes the take-no-prisoners philosophy of the 2010 model that much more surprising. Here's what an unrepentant asshole coach Jim Harbaugh is: His team was up 41-7 on Wake Forest a couple weeks ago, and when the Deacons tried to kick a measly field goal right before halftime in a desperate attempt to save some face and get back a little momentum, Harbaugh called a time-out to ice their kicker. That's the kind of dickishness even the '96 Steve Spurrier would have to bow down to, and it's one of the big reasons why Stanford has become a formidable contender in this category. Just for good measure, it's got a two-way setting that permits it to score on consecutive plays. As with Oregon, we're not entirely convinced that it'll stay completely problem-free for an entire fall season in the more unforgiving climates of the West Coast, but we're rolling with it until proven otherwise, or until Harbaugh screams "HADOUKEN!!" and cockpunches a ref on live TV for missing a hold.

Michigan_medium
MICHIGAN | ■ ■ ■ ½ □

Highs: Manages to get a lot of power from a one-cylinder engine.
Lows: Even slight damage may well render it inoperable.
You know how Volvo built brick-square cars for decades, then all of a sudden got a wild hair around '96 or so and went the sexy/curvaceous route? That's kind of what Michigan did three years ago, only instead of going from "boxy station wagon" to "dream machine," they went from "boxy station wagon" to "evil defective Segway that launches its owner over a cliff." It was enough to make us wonder if the brand should be given up on entirely, but they've gone back to the drawing board to give us a 2010 model that instantly puts Michigan back among the contenders in this class. Shockingly, they've done it with a unit that only has one cylinder, but that one cylinder produces as much power as any other engine in this class. The big mark against UM here is that if that cylinder (otherwise known as "Denard Robinson") provides a good 63 percent of the unit's power, so if it's damaged for any reason, the whole thing will be virtually useless and you'll be back to contemplating drinking yourself to death a la Nic Cage in "Leaving Las Vegas." If you're willing to risk some durability in exchange for speed and sex appeal, though, there are much worse choices you could make.

AVERAGE

Kiffin_barkley_medium
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA | ■ ■ ½ □ □

Highs: Still has a talent advantage over just about everybody, easily portable.
Lows: Erratic handling is going to get someone killed one of these days.
Long a staple of this competitive class, the USC model is back for 2010 and . . . making some strange choices, to say the least. Bringing back the mercurial designer who helped create the justifiably lauded '05 and '06 models was one thing, but the 2010 model's engine-management system contains a chip programmed to go for 2-point conversions seemingly at random; after nearly a month of use, we're still trying to decide whether it has a mind of its own or no mind whatsoever. So-so QB protection, too, means that young kids like Matt Barkley and Mitch Mustain might just be liable one day to reach in and get maimed in some horrible fashion. The 2010 USC does get results, for the most part, but until these safety issues are addressed we can't give it our top recommendation.

Lawnmower_medium
WEEDEATER WE-ONE 96022007 | ■ ■ ½ □ □

Highs: Inexpensive, easy to fuel, will totally chop a D-lineman's fingers off.
Lows: Suitable for light duty only; not nearly as sexy as a John Deere.
The WE-ONE brings up the rear in terms of price in this category, but sometimes you get what you pay for, and this looks like one of those times. It'll mow down small yards and cupcake opponents with ease, but the 190cc engine really just isn't suited for anything resembling heavy-duty work; we found numerous defensive backs who were able to outrun it with ease, and being able to dismember someone with whirling blades is only so much of an advantage when your intended target is five yards ahead of you and widening the gap. (Obviously, this doesn't apply if you're facing a Big Ten team.) We'll go ahead and recommend the WeedEater for buyers with small, manageable yards, but if you're stuck with poor field position and have more than 50 or 60 yards to cover, this one just isn't going to get the job done.

BELOW AVERAGE

Bill_stewart_medium
WEST VIRGINIA | ■ ½ □ □ □

Highs: Kid-friendly operating instructions make it really fun when it's late at night and you're drunk.
Lows: Too many extra features it'll never use -- who really needs a "whittle" setting?
In some ways, the down-home design and extreme officiousness of the West Virginia unit is refreshing: For the next three months only they'll throw in a bagger and a wood-chipping attachment free of charge. We can't help but wonder, though, whether it's all just being used as a distraction from coach Bill Stewart, a coach who makes Houston Nutt look like the very model of stable self-awareness. The criminal underuse of high-powered running back Noel Devine is probably its greatest deficiency; we wouldn't be surprised to find that Stew has that "Memento" short-term memory loss deal and has to be reminded at halftime of each game that Devine is on his roster in the first place. WVU competes in, shall we say, the lower echelon of this category, so they may very well win their conference and go on to a BCS bowl, but if that does happen it'll almost certainly be by accident.

Georgia_medium
GEORGIA | ■ □ □ □ □

Highs: Good young QB, easy to steer, also makes smoothies.
Lows: Weak horsepower means it gets hung up on even the smallest obstacles.
You always know what you're going to get when you go with Georgia in this category: slow, steady, point-A-to-point-B production that could bore the paint off a wall but is still good for eight or nine wins at the bare minimum. Unfortunately, it looks like the 2010 model doesn't even reach that degree of competence, and we're kind of at a loss to figure out why. Frankly, there's just not enough horsepower for them to accomplish anything meaningful on the field; put 'em up against something as minor as moderately heavy brush or Arkansas' D-line and the unit will just sit in one place, futilely spinning its wheels until somebody points it in a different direction. Strangely, the one change from last year's model -- the QB unit -- is pretty much the only thing that's any good on the 2010s; we don't know quite why that is, but there's no denying there have been some major lapses in quality control at the Athens factory over the last few years. We'd stay away from this one until either it cracks 30 points against a decent opponent or the onboard computer overrides the malfunctioning BOBO 4.2 engine-control module, whichever comes first.

NOT ACCEPTABLE

 

Notacceptable_medium
TEXAS | X

LSU | X
We're just as surprised as you are to see these two name brands sitting here, considering that both took home "Best in Class" awards in the last five years. But perhaps those awards bred a little bit of complacency in each one. The decreasing emphasis Texas has placed on the run over the past few years has finally come back to haunt them; it's one thing when you've got an experienced O-line and a guy like Colt McCoy to pick up the slack, but when you start shuffling the line and replace McCoy with a first-year starter, what you end up with is a unit ripe for evisceration by a guy who was very recently getting booed by his own fans at his postgame presser. LSU, meanwhile, is satisfactory in run mode but an utter disaster in either of its "pass" settings; basically you've got options, a gear that only completes passes to the other team or a gear that doesn't complete passes to anybody. The brand is known for being quirky, and it's certainly developed a devoted cult following, but at this point those fans are going to have to prepare for the possibility of cornerback Patrick Peterson finishing the year as their leading scorer. Neither one of these products inspires much confidence in their ability to go the distance, and as such we regretfully give both of them our Not Acceptable rating.

Comment 56 comments  |  1 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Every Day Should Be Saturday

THE CFB BUYERS' GUIDE: RIVALRIES

Nov 2010 by Doug Gillett - 468 comments

THE CFB BUYERS' GUIDE: MASCOTS

Nov 2010 by Doug Gillett - 304 comments

Comments

Display:

agreed.

I needs one that embiggens, forth with.

I'm in no condition to drive...wait! I shouldn't listen to myself, I'm drunk.

by That Other Dave on Sep 28, 2010 2:24 PM EDT up reply actions  

Arboreal analingus. What's not to like?

My name is Cliff Harris, and I’m here to lock shit down.

by HoodRiverDuck on Sep 28, 2010 2:46 PM EDT up reply actions   2 recs

Reality Bites Dept:

I actually like that there are some cheerleaders (at Stanford, for example) that look like real, average or above average looking student babes.
Unlike USC’s or even ucla’s, many of which, look like super model types.

by SKLM on Sep 28, 2010 2:54 PM EDT up reply actions  

Go for the dented car, the dead-end job, the less attractive girl!

I’ll take my cheerleaders hot as fuck, thank you very much.

My name is Cliff Harris, and I’m here to lock shit down.

by HoodRiverDuck on Sep 28, 2010 3:10 PM EDT up reply actions  

I’m pretty sure that SLKM was suggesting that this was a good idea for other universities.

Not being single or a student, this is an entirely academic question for me, and to be honest if the opportunity came up, I wouldn’t turn down the Stanford cheerleaders because they weren’t as hot as the Oregon ones.

"When the seagulls follow the trawler, it's because they think sardines will be thrown into the sea"

by DC Trojan on Sep 28, 2010 3:32 PM EDT up reply actions  

Don't worry, fantasy is healthy.

My name is Cliff Harris, and I’m here to lock shit down.

by HoodRiverDuck on Sep 28, 2010 3:37 PM EDT up reply actions  

I'll take one of each please...

and I don’t those girls from Stanford are going to end up in dead end jobs. Not if all that raving about academics and AAU schools that devidee does is true…

President of the Free Ron Franklin Society.

by Oscar Whiskey on Sep 28, 2010 3:49 PM EDT up reply actions  

knowing full well that I will sound like a jackass...

If you have a 1 cylinder engine and the single cylinder fails, wouldn’t that result in a total loss of power? Or is this analogy complex enough that you’re factoring in Denard Robinson getting dinged up being equivalent to a compression problem?

"When the seagulls follow the trawler, it's because they think sardines will be thrown into the sea"

by DC Trojan on Sep 28, 2010 2:25 PM EDT reply actions  

that question wasn't on the review

I’m reporting you to the dean

President of the Free Ron Franklin Society.

by Oscar Whiskey on Sep 28, 2010 2:29 PM EDT up reply actions  

I found a picture of the Michigan offense for you:


Designed specifically for the Michigan fan who doesn’t want to have to stand up to jingle their keys.

I suppose, if it helps, continue drinking. Your mileage may, um,...vary.

by Ancient Chinese Secret on Sep 28, 2010 2:30 PM EDT up reply actions   1 recs

I hope they put some fire retardant on that bad boy or else they’ll be demonstrating an exuberant leap not often seen at home games.

"When the seagulls follow the trawler, it's because they think sardines will be thrown into the sea"

by DC Trojan on Sep 28, 2010 2:36 PM EDT up reply actions  

I’m having a ho-hum day and I thought I’d spread the joy.

"When the seagulls follow the trawler, it's because they think sardines will be thrown into the sea"

by DC Trojan on Sep 28, 2010 2:30 PM EDT up reply actions  

But wait, there's more!

The 2010 Oregon’s navigation system avoids both Tucson and Palo Alto!

I ain't got time fer nonna' yer ding-dang terr' -Charlie Prides Ghost

by ZombieJackTatum on Sep 28, 2010 2:31 PM EDT reply actions  

The Texas and LSU models

Stop screwing around with those models because people get hurt!

¡Viva La Revolución!

by ecuamerican on Sep 28, 2010 2:35 PM EDT reply actions  

I kind of miss Kinsey...

…him and his Orson Welles-esque look.

President of the Free Ron Franklin Society.

by Oscar Whiskey on Sep 28, 2010 2:37 PM EDT up reply actions  

What the hell? Did they put a chicken in a blender?

Most Alabama fans believe the Tide will never lose another game between now and the end of time. I have no evidence before me to suggest that they are wrong.--Dawg Sports

by mrpelicanpants on Sep 28, 2010 3:57 PM EDT up reply actions  

ran over a british dude's foot

President of the Free Ron Franklin Society.

by Oscar Whiskey on Sep 28, 2010 4:20 PM EDT up reply actions  

I can't stop staring

at the first guy’s lack of a reaction

by Twith on Sep 28, 2010 7:00 PM EDT up reply actions  

continuing on the "helpful" comments

Based on the “talented but erratic in actual use” description of USC’s offense, I think we’re looking at something of early 80s vintage that was not yet defying the laws of physics:

"When the seagulls follow the trawler, it's because they think sardines will be thrown into the sea"

by DC Trojan on Sep 28, 2010 2:35 PM EDT reply actions  

Hip, hip, Hooray Dept!

Applauses all around for Monsieur Swindle for the USC coverage.
Fair and balanced commentary just like at Fox ;-)

by SKLM on Sep 28, 2010 2:56 PM EDT reply actions  

Mixed reviews on Nebraska

Our review began with hopes of great improvement over last year’s disturbingly poor model. The first few rounds led us to believe NU had finally fixed a number of nagging quality control and steering issues.

Our only attempt at an FCS lawn, however, yielded staggeringly disappointing results.

One hopes that the issues will be fixed prior to moving into Big 12-2 territory.

"...when the devil says to you: do not drink, answer him: I will drink, and right freely, just because you tell me not to."
— Martin Luther

by Go Big Rev on Sep 28, 2010 2:58 PM EDT reply actions  

Don't forget the Marshall model

Barely functional, yet decidedly simplistic

I like the taste of danger most of all ~ Jonatha Brooke

by MtnEer_in_SC on Sep 28, 2010 3:18 PM EDT reply actions   2 recs

the trim is even the right color!

MSState Football: You want INT's? We got 'em.

by CoastalCowbell on Sep 28, 2010 3:25 PM EDT up reply actions  

Of course!

I like the taste of danger most of all ~ Jonatha Brooke

by MtnEer_in_SC on Sep 28, 2010 3:29 PM EDT up reply actions  

Seriously?

WVU fans want to pick on Marshall’s offense this year? If this was about DBs I’m all for giving them hell, but our O made you guys look silly for the first 3 quarters.

by k00laid on Sep 29, 2010 11:34 AM EDT up reply actions  

Auburn's offense


Not sure if its a good thing or a bad thing.

I'm too drunk to taste this chicken.

by cowcollege on Sep 28, 2010 3:27 PM EDT reply actions   1 recs

And our defense:

I'm afraid I have no choice but to sell you all for scientific experiments.

by boddagettaflyer on Sep 28, 2010 3:43 PM EDT up reply actions  

so going around through belgium is the equivalent of the underneath/relief pass?

“He’s running the same play! Damn you Ted Roof!” -Me, 11/27/2009

President of the Free Ron Franklin Society.

by Oscar Whiskey on Sep 28, 2010 3:46 PM EDT up reply actions  

Is this one as vulnerable to Case Yellow & Case Red

as the orginal? (not that i know what either would be this year, but the history dork in me had to point it out)

/another way to put it would be to take this as meaning that soon the defense will be facing the wrong way.

MSState Football: You want INT's? We got 'em.

by CoastalCowbell on Sep 28, 2010 3:49 PM EDT up reply actions  

Hahaha..oh, sigh.

Actually the Maginot plan worked exactly as intended. What the French/UK forces disregarded was that the Germans would come through the Ardennes in their attack and so there was a thinly held gap between the concentrations of troops to to the north and the formations back-up the line. (Really, the French had some pretty good tanks and other equipment, their tactics just sucked.) So the argument is really, tactical success/strategic failure?

Not sure what the parallel is though. Too late in the day.

by PalmettoTiger on Sep 28, 2010 3:50 PM EDT up reply actions  

Makes you wonder is Shula was the

Schlieffen Plan. Not. Quite. Good. Enough.

MSState Football: You want INT's? We got 'em.

by CoastalCowbell on Sep 28, 2010 3:52 PM EDT up reply actions  

Tactics? Like waving a white flag?

Most Alabama fans believe the Tide will never lose another game between now and the end of time. I have no evidence before me to suggest that they are wrong.--Dawg Sports

by mrpelicanpants on Sep 28, 2010 3:56 PM EDT up reply actions  

Alabama's defense....

Most Alabama fans believe the Tide will never lose another game between now and the end of time. I have no evidence before me to suggest that they are wrong.--Dawg Sports

by mrpelicanpants on Sep 28, 2010 3:31 PM EDT reply actions  

Built for the kill

Most Alabama fans believe the Tide will never lose another game between now and the end of time. I have no evidence before me to suggest that they are wrong.--Dawg Sports

by mrpelicanpants on Sep 28, 2010 3:32 PM EDT up reply actions  

So what you're saying is...it's the vagina from hell?

I'm afraid I have no choice but to sell you all for scientific experiments.

by boddagettaflyer on Sep 28, 2010 3:42 PM EDT up reply actions  

Teeth

President of the Free Ron Franklin Society.

by Oscar Whiskey on Sep 28, 2010 3:47 PM EDT up reply actions  

Multiple rows of teeth

I'm too drunk to taste this chicken.

by cowcollege on Sep 28, 2010 3:49 PM EDT up reply actions  

Hopefully, we can bite one of Cams legs off

Most Alabama fans believe the Tide will never lose another game between now and the end of time. I have no evidence before me to suggest that they are wrong.--Dawg Sports

by mrpelicanpants on Sep 28, 2010 3:56 PM EDT up reply actions  

OM NOM NOM NOM NOM.

If you’re not saying out lout, you’re doing it wrong.

I suppose, if it helps, continue drinking. Your mileage may, um,...vary.

by Ancient Chinese Secret on Sep 28, 2010 6:27 PM EDT up reply actions  

Sadly the Georgia offense is just not the same . . .

without the added horsepower and fulltime 4 wheel drive of the “Moreno upgrade” available on the 2007 and 2008 models. The A.J. Green upgrade model which replaced it sadly spends as much time in the shop as on the road.

by MaconDawg on Sep 28, 2010 3:34 PM EDT reply actions   1 recs

...THIS JUST IN....

@finebaum Finebaum Network
Tim Brando,“If Boise was in the SEC EAST this year, they would win it!”

Most Alabama fans believe the Tide will never lose another game between now and the end of time. I have no evidence before me to suggest that they are wrong.--Dawg Sports

by mrpelicanpants on Sep 28, 2010 4:07 PM EDT reply actions  

Hey, the Ducks addressed the punching problem

And he just had the balls to do what we’ve all been wanting to do anyway.

by AutzenGetsBlounted on Sep 28, 2010 7:59 PM EDT reply actions  

I'll vouch for the validity of this

the was a guy (1) from Oregon that lived in the same dorms as me in Starkville. He had a ‘punching problem’, too. except he generally threw the first one, and accepted the next 30. i only let him ride to the bar with me once. (he didnt have a vehicle)

(also, he went by ‘Ore-gone’. original, i know)

MSState Football: You want INT's? We got 'em.

by CoastalCowbell on Sep 28, 2010 10:27 PM EDT up reply actions  

Boise State = Sweet Tooth

Looks like it’s just a novelty, but you know they’ve got some crazy shit just waiting to surprise an unsuspecting defense.

by SpartanDan on Sep 28, 2010 8:44 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Because College Football is too important to be left to the professionals.

Managers

Img_0172_small Spencer Hall

Small Orson

Screen_shot_2011-08-18_at_2 Holly Anderson

Editors

Lzprofilepictwopointoh_small Luke Zimmermann

Me_tuscaloosa_small Doug Gillett

Trex_small Run Home Jack