The end game of the conference realignment shakeout _should_ look something like what I offer below. Note, of course, that under the current anarchic 'process' my end stage will never happen. Also, I felt free to exclude marginal BCS programs, because its the right thing to do. (By marginal I mean weak attendance, small television audience, NOBODY CARES kind of schools relative to a mid-level member of a BCS conference.) In addition, I break each of the mega-conferences down into their fairly sensible subdivisions, and discover some very pleasant 'tradition restored' phenomena. One final note: I limited super conferences to a maximum of 18 schools, because that's the max that allows playing all your subdivision foes, having a final championship game, and scheduling a reasonable number of non-conference games.
BIG TEN (18 schools)
WEST
Minnesota
Wisconsin
Iowa
Northwestern
Illinois
Purdue
Michigan
Michigan State
Ohio State
EAST
Indiana
Notre Dame
Penn State
Boston College
Maryland
Virginia
Virginia Tech
West Virginia
Pittsburgh
The above is essentially a combination of the Big Ten with an idealized Big East. Weak literally and in tradition football not allowed. Note how the West subdivision is the old Big Ten (yay!) except for poor Indiana. The East is an old-fashioned best in the northeast football competition. Tradition restored!
SEC (18)
ATLANTIC
NCSU
North Carolina
Duke
Wake Forest
Clemson
South Carolina
Georgia
Georgia Tech
Tennessee
SOUTHEAST
Florida State
Florida
Miami
Auburn
Alabama
Kentucky
Vanderbilt
Mississippi State
Mississippi
Here I do the natural thing and combine the ACC and SEC, and return a few out-of-place schools back where they should be. Sorry South Florida, but ain't it great having all three traditiona Florida powers in the same conference?
BIG 16
NORTH
Colorado
Nebraska
Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Missouri
Arkansas
LSU
SOUTH
Oklahoma State
Oklahoma
Texas A&M
Baylor
Texas
TCU
Texas Tech
New Mexico
Note the restoration of tradition, lots of long familiar foes. Feels real natural, and this is what America wants! New Mexico is a stretch but a natural region-and-travel wise.
PAC-14
NORTH
Washington
Washington State
Oregon State
Oregon
Boise State
Utah
Brigham Young
SOUTH
California
Stanford
UCLA
USC
San Diego State
Arizona
Arizona State
Can't get more than 14 into this one, and even SDSU was a stretch. San Diego is a huge television market and a natural for growth in fan base if it gets these sorts of conference opponents.
Of course I offer all of the above for argumentative purposes only. And, hey, if your team is left out that there are two extra spaces in the Big 16 and 4 extra ones in the Pacific 14. However, I don't think there will ever be enough true BCS schools in the west to justify 18 teams in its super conference. OTOH, certainly there are neglected powerhouses in the Southeast that I've excluded at this point. South Florida, I want to offer a personal apology to you, but I just couldn't find a space if I limit maximum conference size to 18. I suppose you (and who?) could be an 'out-of-region' member of the Big 16?


There are 28 Comments. Load Now.
Shortcuts to mastering the comment thread. Use wisely.
C - Next Comment
X - Mark as Read
R - Reply
Z - Mark Read & Next
Shift + C - Previous
Shift + A - Mark All Read
Comment Settings
Live comment alert: Hide it!
Comments for this post are closed.