BLOGPOLL DRAFT, WEEK FIVE: STOIC EDITION
The Blogpoll! Which makes more sense this week than it did last week thanks to the undeniable stink of losing permeating the defenestrated top ten. Apologies and explanations follow below.
| Rank | Team | Delta |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Oklahoma | 4 |
| 2 | Alabama | 6 |
| 3 | Penn State | 3 |
| 4 | LSU | 1 |
| 5 | Texas | 7 |
| 6 | Missouri | 1 |
| 7 | South Florida | 4 |
| 8 | Brigham Young | 2 |
| 9 | Georgia | 7 |
| 10 | Southern Cal | 9 |
| 11 | Utah | 8 |
| 12 | Auburn | 2 |
| 13 | Vanderbilt | 11 |
| 14 | Kansas | 4 |
| 15 | Florida | 11 |
| 16 | Oklahoma State | — |
| 17 | Texas Tech | 4 |
| 18 | Wisconsin | 1 |
| 19 | Ohio State | 4 |
| 20 | Connecticut | 6 |
| 21 | Northwestern | 5 |
| 22 | Michigan State | 4 |
| 23 | Virginia Tech | 3 |
| 24 | Boise State | 4 |
| 25 | Ball State | 1 |
Initial proviso: Alabama could just as easily be number one. They might very well be the best team playing the best football in the country, but we’ll happily admit that the reason Oklahoma is up there despite blowing the doors off the flimsiest of opponent prior to this weekend is that they’ve been better with the established Stoops Performance Machine longer than Alabama. That is the only thing keeping Alabama from that spot in our minds: the established performance of the Sooners over time. In terms of 2008 resume, Alabama’s performance is the strongest in the nation, and a brutal, brawny kind of strong, not a bronzered-up Mr. Olympia-kind of strong. (See: USC.)
Top ten notes: Penn State might really be that good, and we’ll ride that like the MARTA until it breaks. LSU sleptwalk a bit against Mississippi State, but given the MSU offense, it’s hard not to put up your feet and watch them shriek as they tase themselves over and over again; therefore don’t take a one spot drop too seriously–especially when they have the best shot at Alabama down the road. (Tennessee? Auburn? Have you seen Chris Todd’s fungo game? It’s unstoppable.)
Still weak on Missouri, whose defense brings the butt every other game, but Texas’ defense and the newly efficient Colt McCoy bull Texas up a few notches. BYU and South Florida because who the hell else goes there who’s actually played someone? And Georgia over Southern Cal because the Bulldogs actually lost to a really good team who did not lose to Stanford. (For contrast, see Oregon State’s pissypants performance against Penn State and then reprocess in light of their play against USC, and the continual bullishness for Penn State makes at least a bit more sense.)
As for what Auburn is doing there….the minute someone has a good day against that defense, they get served their eviction notice from the top ten, because their offense set next to Tennessee’s killed the ghost of Bill Walsh yesterday. You didn’t think ghosts could die? They couldn’t until…whatever that was happened. Chris Todd: 14/23, 93 yards, 1 TD/1 INT. Gack.
There is no safe word for this take your whipping. Florida and Wisconsin’s losses were both shameful in nature, and they eat hot ranking death for it. Wisconsin’s may have been the worst in nature–a collapse with a 19-7 lead–but losing at home in a ridiculously error-prone and fitful effort has its own unique and foul odor, too.
The rest is a weeping mess. Oklahoma State/Texas Tech are the same team, and haven’t played anyone, and just sit there like a stubborn bolus in the middle of the poll. Vanderbilt is up there, meaning they’ll lose when Gameday curses them and forces all of us to drop our monocles and flashy canes in shock. Ball State gets a shoutout at 25 because we want to get Jeff George’s autograph via Jason Whitlock, because he is our hero (for stealing good money from a successful corporate entity for years without being caught.)

4
1 







51
Socraticsilence says:
Nine things Orson-
1) Meyer should have sacked up and jump passed on 4th and 1, though given the fact that this was one of the only times, ever that I’ve seen Tebow fail (even when blocking breaks down he usually wills that to being a 1st down- seriously this not the athleticism is why I thought of him as VY), I think this game is where the missing CI hurt us, if we had both him and ESPN (dumbest nickname ever- possibly) we could Double TE and frankly destroy a lot of teams, CI was the security blanket and I think his absence kills us (Bubba was the other one).
2) Can Florida please recruit a kicker, we’ve lost at least one of these games every year I’ve been a Gator fan and I’m 26.
3) With Moody down and the line hurt, I think Tebow actually may have given his best performance in the 4th quarter of this game- seriously this was the first time that I thought he looked like a possible Top Flight pro-QB, I mean until now I was always worried that in a Clutch situation we’d be screwed (see the UM game, when the run is taken away due to time Tebow didn’t have any answers on the final drive, here until the smash he was pretty fricking good– better than Stafford at least) .
4) Percy Harvin is like Reggie Bush with K. Moore’s hands, seriously take away the fumbles and he was the single most dominant guy I’ve ever seen at that hybrid RB/WR position ever.
5) I am terrifed about how we’ll play in 2 years when Tebow’s gone, seriously what the hell can we do if that’s how our offense works and we don’t have another Tebow (Cam’s a tank but he seems weaker than Tebow as a passer, and Brantley’s white Leak without the beautiful no-pressure passing skills).
6) Given our respective rates on line attrition the Cocktail party maybe the frist all A-11 offense game, seriously I wouldn’t be shocked if both the Dawgs and Us enter Jax with like 1 starting lineman remaining.
7) Major Wright- how can you look like RFN 90% of the time and Tony Joiner in the Clutch, seriously dude if you’re like this next year I’m going to be kind of shocked.
9) I think you have UGA way too high, there loss was nearly USC-OSU (buckeye edition) bad, with 3:01 to play the score was 41-17 those 2 tacked on scores shouldn’t cover up that fact, conversely you are as usual too hard on us, we lost by 1 on a fluke play to a team that’s not as bad as there record indicates (2 plays from being undefeated)– to a coach that’s maddeningly good at this crap (he’s like a slightly better redacted– good for 1 or 2 shockers a year both on the positive and the negative– Arky Fans are the least greatful people alive; seriously you’re the freaking Hawgs, and you had 2 awesome RBs what the hell did you expect 50 passes a game you had a good coach not Fulmer), I think if Moody’s not done for the year (unsure of his status) and the line can come back a bit (can we bring the twin who was converted back to offense?) we can still run the table– LSU and UGA are still the teams that scare me (Bama could kill us up front on D but there O actually plays to our strengths).
Good, I’m rambling the one game I wake up late and miss the first half of (Mountain Time, stupid MT school) and we freaking lose.
September 29th, 2008 at 1:53 pm
52
allaha says:
No. 37
We are members of the same tribe.
While there is no doubt that OU is talented, their wins hitherto are not as impressive as Alabama’s.
Unfortunately, saying there is hope for teams that can get through OU’s line is analogous to saying there is hope for armies that can withstand the Russian winter. True, but it does not provide much solace.
If Texas can find a running back, they will give OU a good game; otherwise, Colt is going to get killed.
September 29th, 2008 at 2:29 pm
53
Adisappointederin says:
see what happens when you not only loose badly, but do it right in front of Erin Andrews, West Virginia? NO LOVE.
Sorry Erin. Let us make it up to you. You’re a reader here, right? Didn’t we have fun at the Pitt game 2 years ago? Not last year, silly. Remember that? Come to the Auburn game. And we’ll stop calling all the time.
September 29th, 2008 at 2:46 pm
54
Papa Lou BSU says:
You’re right, Edsall is God… what has BYU done, really? *Real* teams squeak out home wins over Baylor and need overtime to win 12-9 against… Temple. Yay?
September 29th, 2008 at 2:56 pm
55
blon says:
#52
I can see your point about Alabama.
On OU’s O-line, I’m just an optimist. Probably an irrational one, but an optimist none-the-less.
And I do believe we will find a running back soon.
I also believe Congress will work together and get a bill passed to curb this economic downturn…
September 29th, 2008 at 2:57 pm
56
PW says:
I guess the way to stay in the top ten is to lose to unranked teams at home ( Florida) and teams that can’t score points (LSU).
Not a single team in Orson’s top 10 has lost to an unranked team at home. Also, LSU is averaging over 35 points per game.
September 29th, 2008 at 3:03 pm
57
John says:
I put Alabama as #1 over Oklahoma because the quality road victory, but Oklahoma is pretty much #1a. With Texas, Missouri, Texas Tech, and Oklahoma State, I can’t wait for Big 12 conference play to begin.
September 29th, 2008 at 3:07 pm
58
Bama fan@THEcow college says:
i’m glad bama is at #2 …the dawgs 2nd half blackout comeback was the thing could’ve happened …nick can keep ‘em hungier by chewin’ ass during ea week for each more hyped game (see lsu, barners) …plus remember last #1 for the Tide they were only a #2 (at best, not all year) that season and were discounted and dismissed until they kick the u’s ass in the Sugar Bowl ..rtr …sec rules !.
September 29th, 2008 at 5:50 pm
59
Bama fan@THEcow college says:
“the blackout comeback was the BEST thing to happen”
sorry
rtr
September 29th, 2008 at 5:54 pm
60
Bama fan@THEcow college says:
love to see an old school matchup ‘tween The Crimson Tide and PS nitany lions in the b(c)s title game …how kewl would that be, eh ?? …oh well jest my 2 cents …rtr …
September 29th, 2008 at 6:03 pm
61
Graysnail says:
@ Edsall: Well, who would you move in that spot? Utah’s the next undefeated team in there – Mountain West. Texas Tech has a negative strength of schedule, so: same argument. Really, you have to go all the way down to …what, Vandy, maybe, before running across a team that a) has a solid body of work and b) is undefeated. But putting Vandy in the top 10 is tempting the Fates (and yes, I do mean the Greek mythology ones in this case) just a little too much for us just yet.
I mean, you *may* be right – BYU may not be top 10 material. But aside from the top 6 (you can add USF if you want), who do we know – based on talent and body of work – is good yet? You can poke holes in everyone, and hey, *someone* has to be ranked 7th.
September 29th, 2008 at 6:06 pm
62
boogerville says:
Shame. Perhaps if a lack of it during appropriate times caused a debilitating condition (such as scurvy or baldness) aOSU fans might be a little more apt to exhibit some.
September 29th, 2008 at 7:31 pm
63
Justin says:
19-7? Sure, Wisconsin had that lead. They also led 19-0 at the half.
September 30th, 2008 at 9:16 pm