CALLING YOUR OWN PLAYS. LIKE A MAN
Mike Gundy will call his own offensive plays this fall like a man, who is forty-one. This always seems to loom larger–and generate a tad more angst among fans–for offensive coaches than those head coaches with their fingers in the defensive mix, as if it took so much more brainpower to score points than to prevent them. (An unfair prejudice in both directions: see Will Muschamp and Mike Debord as examples to the contrary in both departments.)
There are differences, of course: defenses won’t resort to quite as many alignments and variable assignments as offenses, and therefore the slightly higher level of potential complexity. Defenses have to read them, of course, meaning it’s just as mentally complex, if not more so for players actually on the field.
Nevertheless, scheme has its own romance, and therein lies the public teeth-gnashing over Spurrier devolving play-calling to his son, or Friedgen going back for what seems like the nth time and handing off play-calling to the loving arms of James Franklin, who will run the most affectionate practices in all of college football , or to the continual praise given to Mike Bobo, who took over from Mark Richt at UGA.
The move allowed Richt to be the emotional manbear and not so much of the cerebral field general, thus generating the precise response Richt was hoping for: a sea change in how the team related to him and to each other, and thus the Jacksonville Dance Party, Bowl Annihilation Drill, and everything else good that happened to UGA in 2007.
This is not always the outcome: Friedgen called his own plays for four years, then switched course for three years, and is now reversing field again after a middling outcome pulling the strings himself. Gundy’s own move could yield equally mixed results, hopefully generating not only fodder for healthy, well-reasoned online discussion (”FUCK YOU, SHITEATER!”) but a second and more spectacular still implosion of Coach Krakatoa on camera.
We’re not of any particular mind on the matter, an attitude thus bringing us to Notre Dame, who in terms of antipathy/sympathy we’re not of any particular mind on, either. Charlie Weis cashed in on the Godlike CEO theory of coaching value before Nick Saban broke the standard for Godlike CEO pay, banking on his playcalling ability to give them the “decided strategic advantage” leading Notre Dame back to echoey greatness. His is the second most surprising (next to Spurrier’s, whose ego is just a few hemispheres larger than the OBC’s) given his initial sell and Weis’ obvious zeal for play-calling.
The good news for Weis is that the move will work brilliantly, or will at least appear to work brilliantly, due to the timing. Notre Dame, having hit bottom, will improve against an easier schedule and with the benefit of a healthier, less concussed Jimmy Clausen at qb. Whatever luster is lost by the play-calling move will shift and grow in the Program Manager stock, thus planting the seeds for “Charlie Weis Becomes A Head Coach” stories sure to pop up somewhere around mid-October in the press.
(We’ll bet you whole infant relatives on these surfacing. Seriously. Your cash; our live infant relatives. Consider it a deal.)
You get the baby. We keep the box.
The fun part will be the inevitable reversal when, in an ironic twist, Weis retakes play-calling duties at one point in the future. Pulling the management lever once means you’ll pull it twice, or three times if necessary in order to placate the natives. The only bet to make isn’t whether it will happen, but whether it will be faster than Spurrier’s rush to the clipboard. (It won’t be. Spurrier may take over play-calling during warm-ups against NC State on Thursday afternoon. He’ll look like a man who rolled in poison oak and powdered glass if he doesn’t have some hand in play-calling.)










1
hobeg8r says:
Although I speak only for myself – I am pretty confident to say – that on behalf of the Gator Nation – anything that comes close to comparing the OBC with Weis is too close for comfort. With SOS, we had a proven winner in the SEC (just ask Phil). Charlie Weis is nothing more than a snake-oil salesman who cheated his way through the NFL. Steve may pull the lever because he believes he can do a better job. (Which he can). Weis will pull the lever in desperation.
August 26th, 2008 at 2:34 pm
2
The Song of Hiawatha Francisco says:
I received a “FUCK YOU, SHITEATER!” in three proficiency categories on my last performance review.
August 26th, 2008 at 2:45 pm
3
Crabapple Buck says:
With “a decided schematic advantage” ND was 3-9. What will they do now. Jimmy is already down to 3 Heisman trophies.
Who believes the OBC permanantly relinquishes play calling?
August 26th, 2008 at 2:50 pm
4
wooooooohooooooo says:
“defenses won’t resort to quite as many alignments and variable assignments as offenses” –
How do you figure? Offenses typically utilize a matrix of (Formation + 11 Individual assignments) to determine the play, in a more structured and modular fashion. Defenses tend to be more organic, like an ad-hoc arrangement based on the offensive tendencies. IMO this results in more unique alignments and variable combinations for the D.
August 26th, 2008 at 2:51 pm
5
Orson Swindle says:
Woooohooooo–
We’re probably saying the same thing, though you more explicitly: the offense is more variable in the setup, the defense in its reaction.
August 26th, 2008 at 3:01 pm
6
NRBQ says:
O. -
Will the EDSBS Fuck You, Shiteater tee-shirts be ready by the FLA-UGA game?
August 26th, 2008 at 3:18 pm
7
BeaverJohn says:
Speaking of Mike Gundy, are there any odds on the next Big XII coach to meltdown in a press conference? Also, can we play “Coach with Memorable Press Conference” bingo over the next season, or is that lame?
August 26th, 2008 at 3:18 pm
8
blon57 says:
#7
I’ll take odds on Leach. Better yet, during a game. Yelling at a referee who graduated from an unspecified university.
August 26th, 2008 at 3:23 pm
9
SC_Gator says:
I seem to recall the OBC already saying he was still drawing up and designing plays, just not doing the actual calling. He’s only half gone, therefore he’s already half back.
August 26th, 2008 at 3:34 pm
10
kyle N says:
Mack Brown used to call the defensive plays at UT, now he has decided rightly that he sucked at it. Finally got a real defensive coordinator.
August 27th, 2008 at 7:25 am
11
kyle N says:
{{Speaking of Mike Gundy, are there any odds on the next Big XII coach to meltdown in a press conference? Also, can we play “Coach with Memorable Press Conference” bingo over the next season, or is that lame?}}
My money is on Dan Hawkins.
August 27th, 2008 at 7:28 am