AIRPORT STUCK
Stuck in the airport, and cursing the nation of slackers who get up three hours behind we proper Christians on the east coast. What other madness do you people embrace? Exercise? Using your spoon as a fork? Ass-groping former weightlifter steroid freak Austrian governors?
The net result for us in experiencing the NCAA tourney from the vantage point of deep inside the smoky anus of Vegas is this: college football must never, ever have a playoff. Nevah. That’s our gut instinct right now after having watched the weird dénouement of the tourney’s first weekend in Vegas and realizing that the NCAA cannot effectively coordinate the mating of two donkeys, much less a major football tournament.
Because we’re typing this off our phone while waiting in line to be told that we’re not making our connecting flight in Phoenix, we’ll be succinct: the season remains everything in college football, and a playoff would tangibly devalue the regular season’s value. Man on moon, yes; but seeing the dispassion of turning the game into a neatly compressed lump of productmeat suitable for easy heat ‘n bake consumption made us irrationally sad.
As it stands, every team with a decent body of work gets their one moment in the sun, unless they get the Motor City Bowl, in which case they at least get a moment of glory in the rain of fiery ashes and locusts that has been pelting Detroit for 40 years or so. A playoff kills that dead.
Onto the plane. It’s strictly working on the lizard brain level right now, but the image of a season easily ended in tidy fashion on four screens in Vegas makes us want to split the rails of a playoff train’s tracks and watch the wreck ensue.
It’s just this weekend’s Colbert gut instinct, but it’s there.












25
Wow, that was a really long post.
Comment by Big Jon — March 24, 2008 @ 12:54 pm
24
This really brings up fundamental differences in college football and basketball. The football championship is based on the entire body of work from week 1 until January, whereas the basketball championship awards the team that is best at the end of the season. When looked at as a competition or game, basketball is more accurate. It doesn’t matter who leads the whole way, it matters who’s ahead when the clock strikes 00:00. I suppose it’s a personal opinion as to which is better or more deserved.
A good starting poing for the arguement: 2001 Nebraska got to the BCS championship game after losing the BXII championship game to a strong Oklahoma team that they had beaten during the regular season, and everyone outside of cornland was pissed, even though their body of work was arguably as good as anyone else’s in the nation. I’m sure it will be brought up ad infinitum on this site, but Oklahoma did the same thing the following year when USC was left out, not getting the BCS point bump from a conference championship game.
Alternatively, Arizona is the lowest seed to win the NCAA tournament since its expansion to 64 teams. As a #6 seed they had plenty of slips along the way but got hot at year’s end. Should Kansas, UNC, or whoever be able to make a claim to some first place votes if they played well enough to earn a #1 seed, especially considering how weak Pac-10 hoops were in the mid/late 1990s? Discuss.
At this point both systems sound flawed. And for the record, CFB playoffs=bad.
Comment by Big Jon — March 24, 2008 @ 12:53 pm
23
Orson, you just made a very good argument for why we shouldn’t ever have a large playoff (> 8 teams) in college football. However, it makes no impact on a playoff for 8 or 4 teams. With that kind of playoff, you can still have bowl games and the regular season would still be very important (particularly if tied heavily into conference championships). You can have your cake and eat it, too.
Comment by ChemE93 — March 24, 2008 @ 12:47 pm
22
Only yankees want a playoff
Comment by 3rd — March 24, 2008 @ 12:06 pm
21
@14: I agree, single-elimination brackets are among the worst ways to determine a true national champion.
Worse, though, is when you have a single-elimination bracket that features only 2 teams.
Comment by asim — March 24, 2008 @ 11:59 am
20
The NBA playoffs are the most excruciating 3 months, or however long it takes. The ABSOLUTE worst playoffs of any sport. Play one game, two days off. Play another game, 3 days off. A single playoff series takes two fucking weeks. Horrible.
Sometimes the best team doesn’t win the NCAA tournament, and that’s just fine with me. Every single game could mean the end of your playoffs….and that’s no different than in the NFL playoffs, which I don’t think anyone has a problem with. And the fact that small schools can make a run like George Mason, or perhaps Davidson this year, is what makes the tournament great.
Comment by Brian O'Blivion — March 24, 2008 @ 11:58 am
19
The 64 field is the worst cut off 96 or 32 or 24 would be better.
In any event what causes Col. Bball reg. season to be irrelevant is not NCAA but all inclusive conference tourney. I mean if Georgia gets an invite while have a terrible regular season then that is what make the reg. season irrelevant.
Luckily Coll Football can’t engineer such a large conf. tourney if it wanted to. So automatically the regular season would still matter more in any playoff scenario.
Give the conference champion (1 game between 2 best teams) a bye in a 24 team playoff for college football or basketball and you will see the regular season matter objectively again in both sports. Slightly less figure skating judging in both sports to boot.
Comment by charnold — March 24, 2008 @ 11:56 am
18
Totally agree, and here are my reasons:
http://roadgames07.blogspot.com/2007/12/in-defense-of-bowl-system.html
Comment by Reed — March 24, 2008 @ 11:55 am
17
All I hear is “blah blah blah… the NCAA is a dirty money whore ” on all accounts.
Comment by ThreenOut — March 24, 2008 @ 11:50 am
16
I have long advocated a conference vs. conference round robin to force schools to play a meaningful ooc schedule. Something like the ACC-Big Ten challenge in bball, except hopefully with better results for the Big Ten. Could you imagine a Big Ten-SEC challenge, week one of the regular season, with opponents determined by conf finish the year before? Vandy could play ND, since they were essentially last in the Big Ten. It would give some serious weight to the conference power arguments at year end and hopefully more clarity in picking 1 vs. 2.
Comment by DL — March 24, 2008 @ 11:48 am
15
One and Done tourney’s are one of the worst methods to determine who the best team is. I have no problem with a best of three series in each round (or best of 5, or best of 7, etc.) like they do in baseball and the NBA, because then you’ve really earned your way to the championship. In a one and done you can get their by getting a hot hand at the right time. Which makes me like Basketball pretty much not at all.
Comment by Carlinthemarlin — March 24, 2008 @ 11:41 am
14
Every game of the season counts…well, until the conference championship game, which is more or less a “playoff” for which team gets to go to the BCS. If every game has to count, there shouldn’t be a conference championship.
Of course, I am all for the playoff system. Here I refer you to this bitingly sarcastic post:
http://cardchronicle.com/story/2008/3/19/222449/921
Comment by uclawarren — March 24, 2008 @ 11:37 am
13
I agree. BCS formula needs a tweaking, but the system is fine as is.
March Madness, strictly as an avenue for determining a National Champion (read: NOT entertainment), sucks.
Comment by AP — March 24, 2008 @ 11:30 am
12
Hurrah, finally someone else agrees with me. Playoff bad, meaningful season good, meaningful non-conference schedule better.
Also, kill the BCS. Why do we need an undisputed national champion? Really, bitching about what team is best is all we have to get us through the offseason anyway.
Comment by Erik — March 24, 2008 @ 11:30 am
11
This is the danger of too much oxygen and alcohol. Playoffs don’t kill the regular season unless you make a selection on beauty-contest rules. Make the selection based on conference records, and you get rid of the beauty contest rules.
I understand it when people just don’t want playoffs because without tradition what would we argue about? But, it’s only a regular-season-killer if you use the ice-skating methods of ranking currently extant.
Comment by DC Trojan — March 24, 2008 @ 11:28 am
10
You live in Atlanta and you don’t have a direct flight? That is best part of living here, nonstop anywhere you want to go. Did TSN make you fly thru St. Louis too?
Comment by Crabapple Buck — March 24, 2008 @ 11:22 am
9
#2 - You didn’t see the iphone in the youtube video of ’shooting the picks’?
I would like to add that the royal we is at this point, more than in the past, is now irony, having been graced with numerous videos of a single bespectacled blogger.
Just waiting on the Pulitzer prize for internet journalism now, operating successfully on at least three mediums, text, video, and audio.
Comment by Brian — March 24, 2008 @ 11:21 am
8
‘Irrationally sad.’
Irrationally, yes. You realize you just launched a triumphant, 15,000-word post by Kyle King.
Comment by Hannibal Montegna — March 24, 2008 @ 11:21 am
7
The fit people were throwing over Arizona State’s exclusion from the tourney was enough to make me never ever want a college football playoff. They may have gotten the 64th team wrong and people were up in arms over it.
Personally I think there is one solution that would eliminate all talk of college football playoffs but ADs don’t have the balls to implement: good teams should play good out-of-conference teams on a regular basis. The sad lesson we learned this year was that if Virginia Tech schedules Youngstown State instead of LSU, VT plays for a national title. It needs to stop. If Ohio State hadn’t pillow fought their way to the big game, we might’ve noticed a little sooner that they weren’t good enough to be in that game. Until some teams man up and schedule peers, there will be plenty of people clamoring for a playoff of some sort.
Comment by Dante — March 24, 2008 @ 11:20 am
6
If it ain’t westside lawya, it ain’t poppin. That’s on my mama.
Comment by Brian O'Blivion — March 24, 2008 @ 11:19 am
5
Nothing quite like nursing a Vegas-sized hangover among the loudspeaker announcements, beeping carts, and wailing babies. Add to that the blinking lights and key of C chimes of slot machines near every gate in the Vegas airport and it’s a recipe for a seizure. Good times.
Comment by Big Jon — March 24, 2008 @ 11:15 am
4
Bitter that football is not near are we? Or did Vegas put a dent in the Swindle Industries’ coffers?
Comment by BurritoBrosShits — March 24, 2008 @ 11:14 am
3
I was stuck in Milwaukee all weekend due to snow, without my laptop, and so I didn’t hear about my brackets being busted until I got in late to New Orleans last night. Bummer.
Comment by Jennifer Farrell — March 24, 2008 @ 11:14 am
2
If I find that you’re posting from an Iphone… i’m out.
Comment by ThreenOut — March 24, 2008 @ 11:08 am
1
The NCAA makes HUD look like a model of organizational efficiency and honesty. Only Coach K would tend to disagree.
Comment by yoyofutbawl — March 24, 2008 @ 11:05 am