I WAS WROOOOOOOOOONG
If we’re playing the Social D, then it’s wrong time…or at least speculative wrong time. A long IM conversation with Russell from Football Outsiders prompted this question: what, if anything, does instituting a forty second play clock do besides put the onus on the officials to spot the ball faster? Even if the take 15 seconds to spot the ball–and watching this laggardly work by an SEC crew in this year’s LSU/Rebels game, that’s fairly brisk–it’s likely a push with the current system. And the more plays bit could come from the variable time that bleeds off the clock while the officials are pushing their walkers around spotting the ball. (Get them some offroad tires on those motherfuckers!)
So the 40 second clock may not be the real problem here, as Russell was quick and correct to point out. We were wrong, potentially, here, if the more logical types we know are correct.
The real-play shaver is still there, though:
“After a player runs out of bounds and the ball is made ready to play, the official will start the game clock. Under the old rules the game clock would not start until the ball was snapped. This new rule will not apply in the final two minutes of the first half and the final two minutes of the game.”
Hrm. it won’t be 3-2-5-e level trimmin’, but there’s some absolute time loss here without the promise of more plays. But that’s not the point here: we jumped the gun here and didn’t do our math correctly. See after the jump for the requisite self-flagellation.













19
Raider Red,
Just waaaaah, sir. The only way the rules could have won you that game is if Tech vs. Texas was the only game of the year played under a make-it-take-it format, and even then only if you scored first.
Comment by Horn Brain — February 19, 2008 @ 1:13 am
18
Thats chop blocked…..I have a headache….The Elder case…..one less scholly and more room for the new blood…..has Saban cut Prothro yet?
Comment by Mr Pelican Pants — February 18, 2008 @ 10:23 pm
17
What if the ref decides to stop and smoke a cigarette, since he’s got all that time? What if a dog bites a player? What if that dog gets chopped block on the next play?
Comment by Mr Pelican Pants — February 18, 2008 @ 10:22 pm
16
#3: The refs *could* have spotted the ball quickly and allowed only ~30 seconds to run off the clock as a result, but they never did. 40 seconds was already close to the norm, even in kneel-down situations - the only time the refs made any attempt to hurry the spot is if the offense is running the hurry-up. In fact, I’m pretty sure I’ve seen at least a couple of kneel-downs that took longer than that.
Comment by SpartanDan — February 18, 2008 @ 6:42 pm
15
If I’m listening to Socila D, I’m drinking whiskey. Must.Stop.At.Liquor.Store.
Comment by Scalz1 — February 18, 2008 @ 4:10 pm
14
Less plays = less football = bullshit.
The out of bounds rule sucks.
I do like the new play clock rule. One less way that refs from Austin can help Mack Brown win.
Comment by Raider Red — February 18, 2008 @ 3:50 pm
13
In all of this mess, I have not noticed if they will still stop the clock on first downs?
Heaven forbid if FOX ever got control of SEC CFB - we’d be deluged with simultaneous small inset screen PrisonBreakSimpsonsfamilyGuy commercials during a 4th and 1 late in the 4th in the UGA/UF game, not to mention the looming vacuousness of Thom Brennerman every weekend instead of Verne.
Comment by yoyofutbawl — February 18, 2008 @ 3:47 pm
12
etsuVol,
Because they pay millions upon millions of dollars for the right to broadcast the games and the commercials make the investment worthwhile. They’re annoying, but the conferences aren’t going to restructure their deals so the networks pay less, and the networks aren’t going to turn down ad revenues for our convenience. The only way that would change is if we stopped watching, and we all know that isn’t going to happen.
Comment by Biggus Rickus — February 18, 2008 @ 3:27 pm
11
Jesus Tapdancing Christo! Just run less commercials! How hard is that? The NCAA always wants to use the term “student-athlete” and emphasize the STUDENT, but everything they do is for money.
Why does CBS have to take a prolonged TV timeout after a score, come back for the kickoff, then take ANOTHER prolonged TV timeout before the first play is run? In the UT/UF game that would have saved like an hour!
Comment by etsuVol — February 18, 2008 @ 3:18 pm