TIM TEBOW WINS HEISMAN, IS CONDEMNED TO MEDIOCRITY
Tim Tebow won the Heisman Trophy this Saturday in New York, an award all but ensuring an end to his lifelong streak of athletic excellence.
“First, I’d like to thank my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ for this award, and for giving me the gifts I enjoyed for so long. Before the awards tonight, I said that you never know when your ability to play the game of football could be taken away from you.”
“Thanks to the voters of the Heisman Trophy, I know that that time is now.”

Tebow could only hold the 25 pound trophy for a few seconds before dropping it. He then asked for some juice.
Tebow, who beat contenders Darren McFadden, Colt Brennan, and Chase Daniel for the award to become the first sophomore to win the trophy, said he plans on entering the clergy now that his career as an athlete is done.
“I’ll follow the example of my boyhood hero Danny Wuerffel and help those less fortunate by preaching the word and working in the community. It would also really help if I didn’t have to throw anything ever again, since I couldn’t toss a sandwich wrapper into a wastebasket with any accuracy now. I would also appreciate not being jostled or bumped.”
A chorus of chuckles rose from the Heisman voters, who included Troy Smith, Gino Torretta, Chris Weinke, and Andre Ware.
“It’s amazing, really, what he accomplished in such a short span of time,” said Eric Crouch, calling from his desk at Ameritrade Omaha. “Excuse me, I’m still at work, and putting the phone down is a complex task I used to perform like it was nothing…but that was before I won the Heisman, of course.” The phone clattered for several minutes before the phone call with Crouch ended.
Tebow’s campaign was, by any measure, an astonishing one: he became the first player to run for 20 TDs and pass for 20 TDs, and averaged an amazing 4.25 TDs a game. Yet even at the ceremony, the rapid dimunition of his physical powers became apparent. See this exchange between Chris Fowler and Tebow:
Fowler: Hey, are you sure you can pick up that trophy with one hand?
Tebow: No, sir, I’m sorry but I cannot. May I please have some help? Suddenly…so…weak…
The well-adjusted Tebow is expected to deal with the change, but past Heisman winners still offered their advice to him as he left the stage.
Charlie Ward: “I blame the Jews for my weakness, along with the ice-cold 2-18 shooting of John Starks in game 7 of the 1994 NBA finals.”
Ricky Williams: “I’d do some yoga, and perhaps some colonic therapy. Oh, and weed. Dude, he’s got to get some weed of the dankest and ickiest kind, and smoke it till his eyebrows fall out. That helps a lot.”
Jason White: “Buy more knee oil. You can never have enough of that stuff.”
Ron Dayne: “Mmmrph arghapgph figfff pizzaaphhh fwnd tpnnnddhhnphhh. I’m sorry, I’ll repeat that. My mouth was totally full when I was talking. I make that mistake a lot.”
Matt Leinart: “He should settle down and have a family, you know. It takes virtually no time off your hands, and when chicks hear you have a baby their panties practically evaporate.”
O.J. Simpson: “I suggest golf…AND DOUBLE MURDER!!! Ha, ha, I’m just kidding. I’m not, actually. I totally killed two people, and I’m not even a war vet or anything. They just let me walk around and shit. It’s UNREAL. Leinart! You said you want Warner done? Okay–I think I can get to him next week, but that’s pushing it. I’m swamped, dude.”
The only two-time winner of the award, Archie Griffin, was unable to comment for this story. Griffin has been on bedrest for 32 years following the awarding of his second trophy, after which he became so weak he could not stand or feed himself. He is said to be happy for Tebow and is also extremely fond of a nice, warm bowl of nutritious chicken broth.
We at EDSBS obviously congratulate Tim Tebow for being so undeniably awesome that even the cataract-eyed Heisman crowd gave him a meaningless award. Darren McFadden, Colt Brennan and the 37 year-old Domino’s Manager living the dream known as “Chase Daniel” also deserve congratulations for attracting the attention of the madding crowd. Badass needs no shiny endorsement, though, as Vince Young will be happy to show you on the day of your choosing.









1
Tim says:
OMG you should have to win the best-player-in-your-division trophy in order to win the Heisman!!!!11!
December 9th, 2007 at 10:17 am
2
jebus says:
O.J. Simpson: “I suggest golf…AND DOUBLE MURDER!!!
Thank the gods you’re back.
December 9th, 2007 at 10:25 am
3
stapler says:
Can Kirk Herbstreit go five minutes on TV without using the phrase “body of work”
December 9th, 2007 at 10:30 am
4
Phil says:
A “lifelong” career of mediocrity isn’t that bad. Look how long Testaverde has been mediocre, that’s pretty cool. And remember when Flutie did that drop kick? That was awesome.
December 9th, 2007 at 10:31 am
5
JB says:
Heisman = Kryptonite!
December 9th, 2007 at 10:46 am
6
MP says:
Should have been McFadden. All those rushing touchdowns aren’t that impressive when you consider that they were all from 3 yards and in. AND I’m sure other qbs could have done it before but their coached actually have concern for their well being.
December 9th, 2007 at 11:07 am
7
Signal to Noise says:
That was worth it alone for the Charlie Ward line.
Brilliance!
December 9th, 2007 at 11:09 am
8
oc phil says:
Welcome back Orson. I have a question for you.
I know you think the Heisman is bunk, but it is certainly a cool thing for fans of a school and gives a shine to the season. Since Florida has recently won both a national championship and now a Heisman, how do the two compare for you?
For me, if winning the whole enchilada is 10 points, I’d set having a Heisman winner at 4, making it to the championship game but losing a 2 and winning another BCS game at 1.
I’m also curious how other fans of USC, tOSU, and other programs with those achievements would rank the personal relative value of them.
And yeah, I realize that Florida does not know about losing the BCS game.
December 9th, 2007 at 11:22 am
9
Mr. Flibble says:
Should have been McFadden. All those rushing touchdowns aren’t that impressive when you consider that they were all from 3 yards and in. AND I’m sure other qbs could have done it before but their coached actually have concern for their well being.
Dude, actually only half of Tebow’s touchdowns came from the 3 yard line or less. The remaining 11 are from 5+ yards out. On the other hand, most of McFadden’s TDs came from 3 yards or less.
So thanks for playing. Try the veal before you go.
December 9th, 2007 at 11:23 am
10
bitterhorn says:
So Orson, dual-broken clavicles from the rodeo camp or what? Get to do any bull castrations, digging post-holes, anything?
I’m convinced the Urbaninator is going to ruin Tebow before he can get into the NFL.
December 9th, 2007 at 11:24 am
11
CLTDawg says:
@ stapler
I’d rather see herbie in the ring with OJ for 5 minutes – no weapons barred match in the steel cage. Pretty boy might last 2 minutes…
December 9th, 2007 at 11:30 am
12
bitterhorn says:
@CLTDawg
Is OJ really the same slayer… I mean, PLAYER without the gloves and the knife?
December 9th, 2007 at 11:34 am
13
The Bull-Gator says:
To be honest, the whole “NFL value” thing is bunk if your favorite league is college. Besides, anyone can succeed in the NFL given the right system. Look at Derek Andersen, who had was bombed out of BALTIMORE but found a place as a good to excellent starter in Cleveland. Anyway, Colt Brennan will probably be the next Kyle Boller at the next level anyway, he’s more of a system quarterback than Tebow could ever dream of being. Ask Timmy Chang about his success in the NFL after playing at Hawaii. McFadden, though . . . good for him losing both times. He’ll kick more ass in the NFL and make good dough doing it.
As to the “Tebow had only short TD’s”, it sounds so nit-picky from fans of a guy like McFadden who had lots of short TDs too and several games where he became suddenly mediocre. Tebow played at a very high level regardless of wins and losses.
Shall we go get the you the “WAAHHH-mbulence”?
December 9th, 2007 at 11:38 am
14
wilbur says:
Now that he’s lost his NFL career, I think I can see what he’s gonna do when he leaves college.
December 9th, 2007 at 11:57 am
15
Domer Guy says:
“I’d like to thank my Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ for giving me the ability to play football. I’d like to thank my coaches. I’d like to thank my family. I’d like to thank the fans. I love being a Gator, and Gator Nation. I’d like to thank my Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ for giving me the ability to play football. I’d like to thank my coaches. I’d like to thank my family. I’d like to thank the fans. I love being a Gator, and Gator Nation. I’d like to thank my Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ for giving me the ability to play football. I’d like to thank my coaches. I’d like to thank my family. I’d like to thank the fans. I love being a Gator, and Gator Nation. I’d like to thank my Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ for giving me the ability to play football. I’d like to thank my coaches. I’d like to thank my family. I’d like to thank the fans. I love being a Gator, and Gator Nation.”
I guess they don’t teach communications/speech/public relations down there, do they?
December 9th, 2007 at 12:10 pm
16
The Artist Formerly Known as tOSUBuckeyes says:
Troy Smith called from the corporate headquarters of In-N-Out Burgers in Irvine, Ca.
“Hey Timmy, congrats on winning the Heisman. Have you ever been to In-N-Out Burgers before? I didn’t see you there when we were both in Arizona together; you must have been busy preparing for the National Championship Game. Well anyways, I just wanted to give you a shout and tell you how delicious they are. Next time you are out this way, give me a buzz, burgers are on me. Welcome to the family Timmy.”
December 9th, 2007 at 12:16 pm
17
Piyachi says:
Kudos to Timmah
Now they need a rhino in that crappy truck commercial where everyone chases it (why is Davey Crockett in it?)
December 9th, 2007 at 12:24 pm
18
Coop says:
8 – Since I am not Orson, I will answer.
How do you, as a fan, possibly compare team achievement versus personal achievement?
Maybe Tebow might rate the BCS win over Ohio State a 10, and the Heisman a 4, since HE won it, but what joy do you really derive from it?
Is Sports Illustrated coming out with a commemorative Tebow magazine and DVD? Are there any Florida fans talking smack to Georgia fans or LSU fans this morning? Yeah, didn’t think so.
And, you rate losing the BCS title game lower on your list than the Heisman?
Yeah, a loss sucks, but if you are playing in that game then you had a wonderful season, up until that point, and, in most seasons, you beat everyone in your conference, your rivals, etc.
So, even if you get your ass handed to you in the title game, like Ohio State did last season, only one school in the country can really run their mouths to you.*
* – Unless you lose to an SEC squad, at which point everyone in the SEC will claim the win as a victory not only for their conference, but your school as well, over you and your conference, while conveniently forgetting about the other two bowl games their conference teams lost to teams from your conference.
December 9th, 2007 at 12:38 pm
19
Mr. Flibble says:
Are there any Florida fans talking smack to Georgia fans or LSU fans this morning? Yeah, didn’t think so.
Dude, give is a couple of hours! Most of us are still hung over or just getting up.
December 9th, 2007 at 12:42 pm
20
Dave H. says:
In reading Tebow’s interview with CNNSI’s Gene Menez, it seems like Tebow might be closer friends with Charlie Ward than you realized…
SI.com: What celebrity would you want to meet?
Tebow: I’d have to say Mel Gibson because Braveheart is my favorite movie, and The Patriot is my second-favorite.
Tebow doesn’t say that his third favorite is The Passion of the Christ, and his fourth is Gibson’s arrest video.
December 9th, 2007 at 12:46 pm
21
Coop says:
18 – replace “your” with “their”, in asterisk land in the phrase, “but your school as well,”
December 9th, 2007 at 12:49 pm
22
sjs1959 says:
Tebow has a great NFL future – as a strong safety….
December 9th, 2007 at 12:57 pm
23
Brian O'Blivion says:
Tebow has a great NFL future – as a strong safety…
Tebow threw for more yards, threw more TD’s, rushed for more TD’s, had a better completion percentage, and a better QB rating than Vince Young did in 2005, their National Championship year.
It’s like the old athletic black quarterback arguments in reverse with Tebow.
December 9th, 2007 at 1:08 pm
24
Meg says:
After watching bits of the show as I was channel surfing, all I can say is that they should rename the award ESPN”s Chosen One Award. At least ESPN crew definitely gives full disclosure of its loyalties.
December 9th, 2007 at 1:14 pm
25
Holly says:
Badass needs no shiny endorsement, though, as Charles Woodson will be happy to show you on the day of your choosing.
Fixed….oh. Oh, wait.
December 9th, 2007 at 1:18 pm
26
Roaminggator says:
Congrats Tim!
Your new name on this board is “He15man”.
December 9th, 2007 at 1:38 pm
27
CockDonor says:
To Mr. Flibble – You must be retarded. McFadden’s average TD run was 23 yards. Tebow’s average was 5 yards. I went through and added them all up and did the necessary division to come up with an average. Tebow was 5 yards, J. Lane was 3.3 yards, and J. Lane averaged a full .4 yards more per carry.
Tebow is a glorified fullback.
McFadden is the best player in the nation, bar none.
So, congratulations to Tebow on winning an award he didn’t deserve. McFadden will have a tough time sleeping when he’s the #1 selection in the draft next year.
December 9th, 2007 at 1:47 pm
28
robert says:
Tebow = “Kryptonite” by Purple Ribbon All Stars
December 9th, 2007 at 1:52 pm
29
CliffX says:
As long as this post doesn’t lead to people from Tim’s church posting about how jealous we are of him, I’m happy.
December 9th, 2007 at 1:59 pm
30
CLTDawg says:
@ Meg
It was fairly sickening watching herbie & the crew bruise their knees up licking on Tebow’s sack. It’s cool if he’s your boy, but every other word doesn’t have to be about how you’d love to watch him bang your wife.
And they wonder why there’s a backlash…..
December 9th, 2007 at 2:02 pm
31
Brian O'Blivion says:
Tebow is a glorified fullback.
Glorified fullbacks don’t throw for over 3,000 yards and 29 TD’s. Glorified fullbacks don’t have a passer rating of 177.8 either.
Tebow’s total TD’s = 51 (22 rush)
McFadden = 20 (1 receiving, 4 pass)
It’s not even close. There’s been plenty of RB’s in college football history with numbers similar to McFadden’s. No one has EVER put up numbers like Tebow.
December 9th, 2007 at 2:03 pm
32
Mr. Flibble says:
To Mr. Flibble – You must be retarded. McFadden’s average TD run was 23 yards. Tebow’s average was 5 yards.
Two points:
1. Before calling anyone retarded, make sure you check your math. McFadden’s average ypc on his 15 TDs was just under 18 yards (16, 73, 9, 12, 1, 5, 56, 2, 4, 2, 3, 1, 2, 2, 80). Not 23.
2. As you might have learned in math class, averages are easily inflated by outliers–i.e., those three long runs. His median TD run distance was a rather shorter 3.5 yards, and Tebow wins that comparison too (median TD run = 4.0 yds). So, based on exactly three runs, you demand everybody to ignore the excellence in every other aspect of Tebow’s game both a passer and a runner and a leader?
Nitpicking, indeed. And petty. And pathetic.
December 9th, 2007 at 3:10 pm
33
the modern gal says:
Maybe Tebow can find some inspiration in Vinny Testaverde.
P.S. I hear Archie gave one of his trophies to Peyton, when Peyton asked him “Dad, what’s a Heisman?”
December 9th, 2007 at 3:17 pm
34
Crabapple Buck says:
As a fan of the Buckeyes, I believe Coop has expressed the way we have felt for the last 11 months.
Congrats to Tim Tebow. He is a gentleman and a scholar. I hope Urban doesn’t get him killed in the next season (or two, if you should be so lucky to have hime play as a senior). He seems to be a great kid that anyone would be proud to have on their team. I know that Archie Griffin will welcome him to the most exclusive of clubs if he should be that fortunate.
December 9th, 2007 at 3:17 pm
35
UCLA Mob says:
i’m sure the starving people of Darfur will be happy to know that God took the time to bless Tim Tebow with the Heisman Trophy.
Good player, but havent we all had enough of the rah rah God Squad stuff.
December 9th, 2007 at 3:56 pm
36
Harris says:
I feel bad for TCOAN. Orson will never again have sex without making her wear the Tebow mask.
December 9th, 2007 at 4:02 pm
37
Land of Os(borne) says:
I really don’t give a damn about the Heisman, but I do want to say one thing. Tebow supporters and Florida fans really need to drop the 51 touchdowns thing. It’s not that impressive. Colt Brennan had 56 touchdowns last year and 46 this year and quite rightly didn’t win the Heisman either year. Numbers just don’t matter that much. If numbers won you the Heisman, Dan LeFevour would be atop most ballots. But he’s not.
The Heisman is about highlights, not statistics. The voters felt Tebow’s highlight reel was the most impressive. Nothing wrong with that – make your argument there, Floridians.
December 9th, 2007 at 4:47 pm
38
Kate says:
Orson, re the “the 37 year-old Domino?s Manager living the dream known as ?Chase Daniel?” comment: Ooh, burn.
#16: Seriously, what happened to Troy Smith?
#35: Ehh, unless a kid thanking God on TV because he won an award somehow directly impinges your own way of life, it shouldn’t matter enough to complain about.
December 9th, 2007 at 4:56 pm
39
white-boned demon says:
What was more astounding was how Colt Brennan threw for all of those touchdowns against LSU, Auburn, Georgia, Tennessee and other perrenial powers.
Dan who? Was he the guy from the Norfolk State intramural team that threw for like a million yards and 400 TDs?
December 9th, 2007 at 5:02 pm
40
vegas_buckeye says:
was anyone else amused by the complete and utter lack of punctuation and inflection used in Tebow’s acceptance speech?
ItWasLikeAGiantRunOnSentenceThatJustKeptOnGoingAndGoingAndGoing
His new found mediocrity has already infected his public speaking abilities, and ruined a potentially outstanding career on AM radio.
Either that or he’s a robot who excels at running forward and tossing balls at ridiculous velocity… since age 12… on his knees.
Congrats Tebow, a well deserved award.
December 9th, 2007 at 5:08 pm
41
Steve says:
Psst, hey, Modern Gal…
That was Archie Griffin that won two Heisman’s, not, Archie Manning.
The Manning family is 0-3.
December 9th, 2007 at 5:19 pm
42
Land of Os(borne) says:
@ 38 – white-boned demon
Dan LeFevour is the CMU quarterback with better passing and rushing statistics than Tebow. My point is not that he deserves the Heisman and Tebow does not. My point is statistics do not win the Heisman, so UF fans should base their argument on something else.
December 9th, 2007 at 5:20 pm
43
Kate says:
#40: Heisman curse and robotic tendencies notwithstanding, I think it has more to do with how many blows to the head he’s taken over the past years. Good kid, but maybe too many hits to be a very good orator.
Also, that 12-year-old-throwing-on-one-knee trivia tidbit at the award show was almost too much, even for me. Wondering if ESPN is in love with Tebow is like wondering if Tebow might maybe love Jesus.
December 9th, 2007 at 5:31 pm
44
Brian O'Blivion says:
37- Statistics might not be the only factor in winning the Heisman, but you cannot argue that they don’t matter. They do. When you put the whole package together, Tebow still wins handily.
Leadership? Check
Passing Statistics? Check
Rushing Statistics? Check
BCS competition? Check
Television exposure? Check
Character? Check
The religious background only helps him with the character thing. This doesn’t help McFadden’s cause with that award.
December 9th, 2007 at 5:51 pm
45
Land of Os(borne) says:
44 – Brian O’Blivion
I can agree with that. I’m just trying to break up the 51 TDs = Heisman math that some want to proffer uncritically.
December 9th, 2007 at 5:58 pm
46
Holly says:
Brian, you’re seriously suggesting that McFadden’s CAR not only raises questions about his character, but that its media exposure played a part in the vote tallies? Did I get that right?
December 9th, 2007 at 6:00 pm
47
Brian O'Blivion says:
Holly – seriously, maybe. The Heisman is also a character award, and anything that makes you look “hood” doesn’t help. I’m sure some of the stuffed shirt voters, if they saw that photo, didn’t want it representing their award.
December 9th, 2007 at 6:16 pm
48
Holly says:
How sad. In my mind, that ride is worthy of its own trophy. Perhaps a Humanitas (Advanced) Prize.
December 9th, 2007 at 6:20 pm
49
Bobby Decatur says:
Well, if that’s the case, then Orson’s Pimp Juice post that Slate commented on/linked back in…whenever…is obviously what did D-Mac in. Diabolical Visionary, that Swindle.
December 9th, 2007 at 6:27 pm
50
NewAZTiger says:
The Combined Tebow/McFadden line vs AU
If you took the two players and combined their stats vs AU, this is what it would look like. We’ll call the player “Heisman McHeisman”
Heisman McHeisman
Rushing: 34 attempts for 118 yards (3.5 yards per attempt), 1 TD
Passing: 20/27 for 201 yards (7.4 yards per completion), 1TD, 1 INT.
December 9th, 2007 at 6:33 pm