NCAA COULD NIX TEXT MESSAGING. LEARN SEMAPHORE NOW.
Do we really have to say that any potential ban on text-messaging recruits, or limits, or anything else governing digital communication between recruits and coaches will be happily trampled with three seconds worth of inventiveness?
HUZZAH FOR THE NCAA INTERVENING PROTECTING THE POOR, SLOW-THUMBED ATHLETE WHO LIKE PAVLOV’S DOG SLOBBERS AND HELPLESSLY ANSWERS HIS PHONE EACH TIME A TEXT MESSAGE COMES IN! [/hectoring columnist.]
There’s a period of adjustment to any technology. Initially, you answered every piece of mail that came in your mailbox. Then advertisements, junk mail, odd sample issues of magazines you’d never subscribe to (SI? Not until they bring the football phone back, dammit), and that regular update from International Male your friends so helpfully signed you up for in 1998.
And now you throw half the shit in the trash without looking. Ultimately, that’s what recruits will do with text messages, just as they’ve done with phone calls. They’ll talk with whomever they want, and ditch the rest. Intervention is dumb, clumsy, sloppy, and short-sighted.
Declarative and hopelessly obvious commentary concluded, we now move to the post text-messaging world of college recruiting. With digital means excluded, coaches will have to revisit the world of analog signals transmission. A few of our suggestions follow:

Blimps
Big! Loud! Kids love ‘em, dogs bark at ‘em, and you know you secretly want one of your own to terrorize the skies with. Ideal for impressing recruits with over their practice fields with the message “(INSERT RECRUIT NAME HERE)’S A PIMP.”
Downside: slooooooooooow.
Semaphore.
When restraining orders limit you to the school parking lot, there’s always semaphore. Penn State obviously holds the edge in this department already, since Joe Paterno’s never stopped using it. Here he is warming up his form in the parking lot last season:

Downside: requires someone else who understands semaphore on the other end. Otherwise, you just look like a flag-waving color guard member with St. Vitus’ Dance.
Motorcycle Courier. It worked for Paul Van Riper in Millenium Challenge 02–why wouldn’t it work for your Division 1 football coach?
Mack Brown and Texas may claim a richly deserved advantage here, as Mack Brown’s father once served this exact role as a dashing sergeant in the United States Signal Corps in World War Two, delivering Joseph Stilwell’s laundry orders across Chungking and back through chaotic Chinese traffic with a “dervish-like speed,” according to the general’s memoirs.
How he maintained such a fine crease in his trousers in sweltering Sichuan heat we’ll never know. All we know is that there’s quite a family resemblance, and that we really, really miss our motorcycle.

P.S. Joseph Stilwell is our favorite general evah. Anyone who called Chiang Kai-Shek “Peanut” has our respect.









1
rob says:
Nice Kuomintang reference there, Orson. Staying on the WWII theme, coaches could send recruits messages thru cryptic radio broadcasts like how the Allies sent the French Resistance messages via the BBC.
April 19th, 2007 at 11:48 am
2
Out of Conference says:
Yeah, don’t forget ham radio. Weis and Fulmer are all over it.
April 19th, 2007 at 11:48 am
3
The Conscience of a Nation says:
That football phone sucked– my parents had it in their room, and whenever I would pick up an extension across the house to make phone calls it would chirp. Not so great when calling to confirm escape plans with friends at 1 a.m.
April 19th, 2007 at 11:49 am
4
Rusty says:
Damn. +1 for the Blink reference, Orson. It’s stuff like that that keeps me coming back. That and the joy of getting pissed off at SKLM.
April 19th, 2007 at 11:50 am
5
Bob LaBlog says:
Come on guys, those kids have to pay for every text message they receive from your newest brand of evil genius head coach.
April 19th, 2007 at 11:53 am
6
italiangator says:
I’m guessing that blimp photo had to be taken Jan. 7 or before, yes?
April 19th, 2007 at 11:58 am
7
letsplaytummysticks says:
They are taking away all electronic messaging. How will Bobby Bowden get hold of kids if he can’t use the telegram?
April 19th, 2007 at 11:58 am
8
irishoutsider says:
JoePas going back to telegrams.
Dear recruit. STOP
Penn State good for humors STOP
Message approved by NCAA STOP
April 19th, 2007 at 12:02 pm
9
Brian says:
You forgot about singing telegrams, which incur bonus points for loophole value, as you can just send the strippers to the recruit’s house and not have to mess around with underage drinking and fornicating on school property. “Hey I just hired them to sing Rocky Top, nothing more Mr. Brand.”
April 19th, 2007 at 12:03 pm
10
Mormon T. Suxorz says:
Will the ban apply to coach/ reporters as well? Something tells me someone in Arkansas is going through the fine print right now on this piece of legislation.
April 19th, 2007 at 12:08 pm
11
Andy says:
Don’t forget delivery by golden unicycle.
April 19th, 2007 at 12:11 pm
12
Daniel Adams says:
“Intervention is dumb, clumsy, sloppy, and short-sighted.”
How so? This sounds precise, easy to understand and, more importantly, consistent with an overall NCAA policy of limiting the amount of contact between coaches and 17 year olds.
April 19th, 2007 at 12:15 pm
13
Suss says:
A bright light flashes over the house of a 5-star recruit.
It’s the StoopsSignal!
April 19th, 2007 at 12:27 pm
14
Because They Can says:
No need now for UF’s planned 10,000 sq. ft. Text Messaging Building or the dozens of grad. asst. types sending hourly personal messages directly from the fingers of Urban to Studly Prospect (and the other 250 on the list).
April 19th, 2007 at 12:34 pm
15
Stacy Keibler Luvs Me says:
TCOAN’s 1:00AM Escapes:
My guess is that TCAON escaped at 1:00AM to meet up with friends to discuss noted thinkers: Immanuel Kant, Albert Camus and Alfred E. Neuman.
April 19th, 2007 at 12:34 pm
16
paulwesterdawg says:
Batman Carroll was picked up that Fayetteville Airport by a Batman Impersonator driving a replica Batmobile. That vehicle took him to Houston Nutt’s house on his official visit weekend.
Text Messaging is just one of many issues that probably could use some tweaking by the NCAAs.
Rumors of $200-300 text bills for recruits is what ultimately doomed Meyer and his magic thumbs.
“OMG! ISNF!1! NO MSGs 4 Me! WTF?” – Urban Meyer
April 19th, 2007 at 12:36 pm
17
canuck says:
So lo-tech. Why no Minority Report references?
How many Fulmer Cup points for kidnapping a commit and doing iris transplants to keep [NAME REDACTED] at bay?
April 19th, 2007 at 12:38 pm
18
canuck says:
… or for kidnapping a precog in order to intervene whenever Urby even thinks of going near a commit?
April 19th, 2007 at 12:41 pm
19
adam says:
singing telegram sounds like a good idea, but you have to watch out for land sharks.
April 19th, 2007 at 12:41 pm
20
Orson Swindle says:
Daniel–
It’s all four because it’s so easily circumvented, and because the long-term effectiveness of rapid-fire texting will fade once it becomes an annoyance. It’s a tool, but one that can be overused, as the clamor for this by the Student Advisory Board shows.
However, we don’t want the NCAA to have any more say as a regulator than it absolutely has to, particularly in regards to any contact with recruits by anyone with an interest in football. They write bad policy, interpret rules arbitrarily, and have a command of due process that makes Lionel Hutz look like Clarence Darrow.
For example: what will be an illegal contact between recruit and recruiter? A text message from an uncle who happens to be standing right next to the coach, who says “Come to LSU” via him? Or third party texting?
Ultimately, the tidy thing to do would be to put this on the consumer’s shoulders and let recruits savvy enough to check their Scout rankings and do their homework police it themselves by blocking unwanted text messages and using extreme harassment by coaches as a factor in their decision-making calculus.
Our opinions on this are shaped largely by the book The Victorian Internet: The Remarkable Story of the Telegraph and the Nineteenth Century’s On-Line Pioneers. Great read, if you can get it.
(TCOAN found it for me out of the blue. This is why geek marries geek.)
April 19th, 2007 at 12:41 pm
21
Katy says:
Fellas, I submit the carrier pigeon. Fast, accurate, and if the recruit gets hungry upon receiving the message… well, you know…
April 19th, 2007 at 12:48 pm
22
SunDawg says:
As a former Navy Quartermaster I can confirm that a semiphore message can be effectively worked into a Japanese fan dance.
I like the stripper idea; she could send blinking light messages using the fake diamond in her navel.
April 19th, 2007 at 12:52 pm
23
Orson Swindle says:
Katy: impossible at Kansas, Notre Dame, Tennessee, Toledo, or Maryland as messages would be eaten on receipt.
Also impractical at Ole Miss, as the Orgeron’s stare would knock them from the sky.
April 19th, 2007 at 12:53 pm
24
the walrus says:
Yes, those dastardly land sharks, with their candy grams and unicefs and radio shows.
I’d actually like to see a far more evil and threatening for of instant messaging, like tying a message to a brick and tossing it through the window.
For example:
*crash*
“Cm 2 ARK, we hv gr8 pie n fciltes
brk u l8er
xoxo
Nutt”
April 19th, 2007 at 1:01 pm
25
italiangator says:
I agree with you on this one O- if a recruit is being ‘harassed’ by a coach’s texting him, wouldn’t he just choose not to go there? This seems like something that will be decided by the market, and the new rule seems like a repeat of last year’s clock rules- see a problem, kneejerk reaction that leaves everyone angry, repeal one year later.
April 19th, 2007 at 1:04 pm
26
adam says:
the pie would do it for me, walrus.
April 19th, 2007 at 1:12 pm
27
Doug the future Mr. Theuriau says:
Urban Meyer once sent me a message in my Alpha-Bits. It said, “OOOOOOO.”
April 19th, 2007 at 1:15 pm
28
Go Blue, Eh! says:
Doug,
Those were Cherios
April 19th, 2007 at 1:20 pm
29
Because They Can says:
“brk u l8er” LOL
Italiangator- Hey, don’t look a gift single year rule in the mouth. That transfer thingy worked out pretty well for your boys, I’d say!
I’m not sure why anybody is surprised that the texting thing would be on the chopping block. I expected it last year, particularly after the Tebow recuitment. Besides, the inherent creepiness of recruiting is taken to a whole new level by non-stop, around the clock texts from grown men (theoretically) to H.S. boys.
April 19th, 2007 at 1:27 pm
30
Newspaper Hack says:
I think the problem is the amount of messages. Unless the parents spring for the unlimited messages plan, these coaches are making the athletes’ parents pay out the ass for unsolicited texting.
April 19th, 2007 at 1:35 pm
31
italiangator says:
Actually, BTC, I was (and still am) in favor of the graduation-transfer w/ no penalty rule, because it actually preserves the ’student’ in ’student-athlete.’ If I graduate from a school, which is the stated goal of any university student (whether or not it’s true), I should then be free to go to another school of my choosing to continue that education, with no strings attached. I didn’t sign up to play for a university for 4 years- I signed to play with a university while I work towards a degree. Degree finished, commitment finished. This is actually a question that I’d like somebody to tell me the other side of, because I’ve heard coaches, fans say that they don’t like it, but I’ve never understood why.
April 19th, 2007 at 1:50 pm
32
italiangator says:
Oh, and to respond to the point at hand- I agree with the creepiness thing, but the entire recruiting process and then 4 years later NFL draft leadup is creepy, so this just seems to be a continuation of that.
And Hack, I see the point involved in the money angle, but again, I’d think the market (and the player) can take care of this- if a recruit can’t afford these coaches to be texting him, he should say hey- if you guys send me any more texts, I’m going to eliminate you from my list, because this is out of hand. If on the other hand the recruit can afford it and loves the attention, then so be it.
April 19th, 2007 at 1:54 pm
33
Brian says:
Orson,
I can just see a young Marconi trolling for ass while at his telegraph post:
*– / *** / * — **
April 19th, 2007 at 2:30 pm
34
PJ from NU in SF says:
1) Text messaging is for kids. The only letters I want my coaches playing with are O and X.
2) Stilwell was a dick to everybody, I understand. He’s not someone you would want for a father, but he was hands-down the US Army’s best leg-infantry general of the 20th century.
3) “Victorian Internet” is a great book indeed, and perfect for commuting. Unlike most people I know, I once had reason to send a telegram, about 16 years ago.
4) Myles Brand needs to die, and soon. The only problem that I see is that we could get an even bigger clown in his place.
April 19th, 2007 at 2:36 pm
35
Papa Lou BSU says:
“I think the problem is the amount of messages. Unless the parents spring for the unlimited messages plan, these coaches are making the athletes’ parents pay out the ass for unsolicited texting.”
Indeed. I don’t have a teenager around the house yet, but my friends who do assure me that text fees are not cheap. And that’s for a normal kid who doesn’t have 18 football coaching staffs bombarding them with messages every day.
Kids telling coaches to stop “or else I’ll drop you” is great, but there will still be coaches that will persist, and the kid or his parents will still have to pay those bills (come on, if a verbal to another school doesn’t get most coaches to lay off the recruiting accelerator, do you really think a “dont txt me!” message will have any effect whatsoever?)
I generally side with Orson on this one, but I’d be in favor of an NCAA rule requiring an “opt-in” on the athlete’s part before a school could start sending unsolicited texts.
April 19th, 2007 at 2:42 pm
36
Because They Can says:
I.G.- As for the transfer rule, I think it has the potential to really hurt smaller programs. I don’t like the idea that Mid Major Tech’s star player can bolt for Big Time U to chase championships leaving his old team dangling. I like the deterrent effect of the “sit out a year rule” for normal transfers, and I don’t really see why graduating should change that, especially since redshirting makes the chances of graduating before one’s eligibility expires less remote. I would also hate to see a free agent climate develop with power programs plugging holes by trolling for talent from other programs, or MMT players pimping themselves to BTU for a single year to get a ring and more NFL exposure. I say make them wait a year.
It only took one year (and one player) for the rule to have a huge effect on CFB, though not many seemed to notice. It would have been more in the public eye had the transfer been a star QB, RB, or WR (which would eventually happen).
April 19th, 2007 at 3:02 pm
37
Brian says:
my sister gets unlimited texts for like 10 bucks a month…how are these idiots racking up 200 charges.
April 19th, 2007 at 3:06 pm
38
Out of Conference says:
Brian #33 – I must be losing somethng in the translation,
A-S-L?
April 19th, 2007 at 3:15 pm
39
Eeee-li! says:
Julius Caesar on the aldis lamp? Semaphore version of Wuthering Heights? Smoke signal version of Gentlemen Prefer Blondes?
I submit for your approval:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0vgZ2UNS54
April 19th, 2007 at 3:19 pm
40
Brian says:
Apparently Out of Conference never tried to troll for sluts online when he was 13…
A/S/L means “Age, Sex (M/F), and Location such as:
17/F/Cali (which is pretty much code for: I’m a 50 year old dude and I live in Minneapolis.)
April 19th, 2007 at 3:33 pm
41
Out of Conference says:
Part of me is relieved that I didn’t know that, but part of me is pissed that there wasn’t the technology to do that when I was 13.
April 19th, 2007 at 3:38 pm
42
Orson Swindle says:
You learn something every day.
April 19th, 2007 at 4:42 pm
43
peachy says:
#36 – But he can’t bolt; he has to graduate first. Even if that just means bribing a series of professors to sign off on his independent studies, the athlete has to spend at least three years at the original school (barring massive AP/IB credit, harhar.) You might recall that although Smith did finish in three, he had to bust his ass in summer school to do it.
I agree with italiangator – the rule provided a positive incentive for athletes to actually graduate, thus preserving some tiny shred of amateurism. We may scoff at that notion, but we shouldn’t forget that relatively few athletes – even in a power program like Florida football – are going to make their living as athletes.
April 19th, 2007 at 4:53 pm
44
oc phil says:
I have to disagree with Orson on this one. Letters and phone calls have been regulated by the NCAA since forever. Text messages were invented and a new loophole was born and I’m surprised it lasted this long. It makes no sense for texting to be open season all the time if other forms of contact are not. If you want to take down all the limits on visits, calls, letters etc, then at least you would be consistant. But I don’t think that’s a very good idea since the whole circus would get REALLY get out of control if there were no limits on any contact.
April 19th, 2007 at 7:17 pm
45
Nate says:
Maybe this is just a difference between cellphone rates here in Japan vs. the US, but let me confirm: you have to pay for INCOMING text messages? That’s ridiculous. I’ve got a Softbank (nee Vodafone, nee J-phone) phone here, and not only are incoming emails/text messages free, but sending them to someone else with a Softbank phone (along with phone calls, for that matter) are free. I simply have a monthly fee of around $50. Beats $200 in text fees.
If this isn’t the way things work in the States, then that sucks.
April 19th, 2007 at 8:22 pm
46
irishdevil says:
Gotta disagree with Orson on this one (although the rest of the post was great, especially the blimp idea-still waiting for SKLM or an OSU fan to turn that into a Weis joke). I just don’t see the need for text messaging, period, when other substitute means (email) are available and cost nothing for the recruits and their parents. And I say that as a fan of a program that uses text messages aggressively.
And it is not nearly as simple as blocking a sender, either. Many recruits are only recruited by a couple 1-A schools (in fairness, Gator fans might forget this because Über-recruiter Urban only goes after OMG shirtless 11!1 recruits with 50+ offers). They simply do not have the luxury of telling a staff to stuff it.
Don’t have any idea how text message billing works, but even an extra $10 a month for unlimited texting is a lot of money to many of these kids. Yeah, they can in part parlay the communication with coaches into a scholarship worth tens of thousands of dollars, but I still don’t see the need. Just get the coaches to pick up the phone or send an email, like the good ol’ days of 2003. [Grumble grumble harumph grumble...]
April 20th, 2007 at 4:26 am
47
IJ says:
Orson @ #23
Was that a Jerry Clower reference? Haaawwwwww!
April 20th, 2007 at 9:57 am
48
iluvtexasgal says:
I think Orson’s point was that this new rule is almost impossible to regulate. Urban can just buy a disposable phone from Virgin mobile and send a text message. And what punishment will the NCAA dish out for such an offense? It’s an f’ing text message, it’s not like paying a prostitute to blow a recruit.
Now, as for Orson’s motivation, it’s probably because Urban Meyer is one of two coaches (Pete Carroll being the other) that send out more text messages than Houston Nutt.
April 21st, 2007 at 7:25 am