AAAAGGGHHHH!!!!
We dropped out of the first-run movie consuming public sometime shortly after our family purchased a VCR and a worn copy of Sharkey’s Machine. But here on Mustache Wednesday, we can’t help but ignore the horror being assembled in the studios and backrooms of Hollywood: a rehashed big-screen version of…Magnum P.I.
Why will it suck? Besides the obvious reasons of it being a rehashed television series? A few of our predictions:
1. The shorts won’t be short enough. They just won’t; part of the insouciant confidence that Magnum brought to the screen came via his insistence on wearing pantalones so brief Richard Simmons would balk at them. Magnum didn’t care, and neither did the endless parade of big-haired, generously bosomed, and flat-assed television beauties who waltzed through his waterbed on the show. Some people saw “gay”, but ladies saw easy access and some serious confidence in a nice pair of he-legs.
2. ACTC will be too fit. TC was supposed to look like a guy who drank beer and flew a helicopter. The film version will be someone like Ving Rhames at the peak of a nandralone cycle. TC was tough, sure, but he wasn’t pansy enough to worry about ab work. He was too busy buzzing volcanoes, sleeping with the one black woman who walked in the bar, and kicking ass without caring enough to take names. Don’t believe us? Watch the episode where he beats up half the adult male population of the Big Island to save the orphanage. Bad. Ass.
Inexcusable error–the author has been shot.–ed pps. Not fatally, but he is very badly wounded.–ed.
3. The mustache, whomever may be knighted to wear it, won’t compare. It can’t so don’t try.
![]()
He is all that is man.
*** Stranko’s 2 Cents*** I could get behind this project
IF it were to star a mustachioed Matt Leinart as Magnum and Reggie Bush as TC AND it is directed by Ang Lee and produced by EOE to be shown non-stop on ESPNHD. Otherwise, it is an abomination.












40
Dan Akroyd as Higgins
Michael Clark Duncan as TC
Jason Lee as Magnum
Charlie Sheen as Rick
Comment by Willy B. Stevens — June 14, 2006 @ 10:38 pm
39
magnum is Urban’s man-crush
Comment by jake — January 26, 2006 @ 3:10 pm
38
Johnny Depp as Magnum, Shaq as TC (just because I want to see him fold himself into a helicopter), Kevin Klein as Higgins, and Jery Mathers as The Beaver….I mean Rick. What a twisted tale that cast could tell.
Comment by Bob Sacamano — January 26, 2006 @ 10:36 am
37
What about Dave Wannstedt? He has the stache, plus he needs to get out of the coaching business… doesnt seem to be working out for him, although hes only had TEN YEARS and numerous chances to take a team to a winning record. lol Pitt sucks!
Comment by The Maadman — January 26, 2006 @ 2:07 am
36
I was hoping the classy yet shockingly badass Clive Owen would be picked as the next James Bond. But I’d take Gervais as Higgins, an inspired choice.
Comment by Doug — January 25, 2006 @ 9:19 pm
35
Gervais as Higgins… pitch perfect.
Comment by LD — January 25, 2006 @ 7:37 pm
34
Oooh…we like the Clive Owen call. He looks like he’s always ready to hit something.
Comment by Orson Swindle — January 25, 2006 @ 6:55 pm
33
Jeremy Piven is perfect. May I suggest Ricky Gervais has Higgins? Bernie Mack as TC and regarding Thomas Sullivan himself: In the storied tradition of American heros being portrayed by Brits and/or Aussies, I suggest Clive Owen, Hugh Jackman and Eric Bana. James Denton, regardless of nationality, should be considered as well.
Comment by PSUgirl — January 25, 2006 @ 6:54 pm
32
Ron Livingston could absolutely pull off The Magnum. Anyway, isn’t Selleck like 74 or something? Way too old and fat for shirtless kayaking these days. Nathan Lane as Higgins is genius. Although if he turned it down Chris Barrie might work.
Comment by bitterhorn — January 25, 2006 @ 6:44 pm
31
even though the movie remake of The Mod Squad kind of sucked, at least it turned out to be an extra long episode of the real show. Instead you know this is going to be a Starsky and Hutch “haha, let’s make fun of the clothes (and in this case ’stachery)” sort of deal. Let’s all hope and pray that Ben Stiller keeps his grubby little hands full of misspent potential the fuck off.
Comment by Todd — January 25, 2006 @ 5:36 pm