ATTENTION IOWA FANS: SPIELMAN FEELS YOUR PAIN.
Never one to hold in his thoughts (even when wrong), former NFLer turned ESPN color commentator, Chris Spielman continuously criticized the officiating in the Outback Bowl. Check out some of the high points here. In some cases he was dead on, like the strange face make call on the receiver who was pulled down by his facemask by Vernell Brown, or the roughing the passer call for a phantom helmet to helmet hit. Others he was wrong on the rules, like when he was pissed that they didn’t give Iowa the completion when the receiver was forced out of bounds before landing. On a few, he wasn’t wrong but was perhaps unfair… the running in the kicker call, which I think was the right call as the kicker came down on the attempted blocker without forcing himself into the his path, or, more controversially, the onsides kick in which the replay looked close but it looked as if the offending player was onsides… my biased retort would be that it is a bit unfair to criticize the ref who is standing down the line based on a replay with an angle from 15 to 20 yards away which would tend to distort the view in favor of being onsides…. but then again I am biased. All in all, I enjoyed Spielman’s passion even when he was wrong.

Compliments of the Gatorsports message board, one Gator fan has proof that the whole Iowa team was offsides.












20
The rule in college is that you must get one foot in bounds for it to be a catch. Unlike the NFL, they do not allow a referee to make a judgment call as to whether you would have gotten that foot in bounds if you were not forced out by the opposing player. That was my reference there.
Comment by Stranko Montana — January 6, 2006 @ 3:42 pm
19
‘Others he was wrong on the rules, like when he was pissed that they didn’t give Iowa the completion when the receiver was forced out of bounds before landing.’ So Stranko, exactly what are the rules as you see them. It was clearly a catch. Without the defender taking Hinkel out of bounds, he would have landed in the field of play. That makes it a catch. Do all of you Florida fans have to justify the officials? You won. We lost. I would only like to see the officials review the entire game and explain how they made some of their calls. And DHC - you really need better analogies.
Comment by Chris — January 6, 2006 @ 6:24 am
18
Opps, please delete my last comment, I didn’t realize it was linked in the original post. Sigh.
Comment by Mizidy Mizark — January 4, 2006 @ 1:37 pm
17
To enjoy a number of Spielman’s outbursts, the DM Register has a transcript of a number of his outbursts.
Comment by Mizidy Mizark — January 4, 2006 @ 1:36 pm
16
The coordinator of Conference USA officials released the following statement: “Out of approximately 175 plays in this game, we have five under specific review–including an important call at the end of the game. We do teach our officials that toward the end of the game, the calls should clearly be a foul. In this case, the onside kickoff call was too technical and should not have been made.”
Comment by Trader Kevin — January 4, 2006 @ 12:41 pm
15
I took a look at your rendition of the badly photoshopped picture. You have only done the lines based on the heads of the players… if the knee is in front of the head, then that is the line you should use… which would still appear onsides in this picture, but it will be close.
Comment by Stranko Montana — January 4, 2006 @ 11:04 am
14
I picture posted of course is actually a joke given the obviously bad photoshop job… as for the in bounds catch… you are allowed in the college game to knock someone out of bounds, Spielman was referring to an NFL rule which does not exist in college.
Comment by Stranko Montana — January 4, 2006 @ 11:02 am
13
As an Iowa fan, I won’t deny my own bias, but I think that the onside-kick picture is at best “inconclusive”.
the link has my adaptations to the pic; i think the picture submitter must have failed geometry. my picture is hardly conclusive, either, but recognize that the guy at the bottom is behind the line of scrimmage, by about the distance given by the horizontal-ish line. that puts greenway at the line of scrimmage. back him up a few inches to place him where he was when the ball was kicked (note that schlicher the kicker’s foot is about a foot in the air and the ball is nowhere to be seen) and we may have a bad call.
i’ll agree with Mizidy Mizark, though, that we didn’t play very well to begin with.
Comment by krakatoa — January 4, 2006 @ 3:23 am
12
This was by far the worst officiating crew assembled. Spielman was correct on almost every account. First, the imaginiary face mask? huh?, a ticky-tac roughing the kicker (perhaps the closest call), a helmet to helmet or roughing the passer penalty - what? The helmets never hit, the QB was a runner and he was hit at the same moment he started to slide. Horrible call. Then the clear catch by the Hawkeye receiver IN BOUNDS. His shoulder even landed in after he was attempted to be knocked out of bounds. Another blown call that would have clearly kept the drive alive. Then lastly the off-sides call. This call clearly sums up what happened (see picture above - you can’t argue a picture - anyone who thinks Iowa was off sides is a DUMB ASS!!! and needs a good ASS whoopin!)- a superior Big 10 team in a bowl game playing in Florida’s back yard. Iowa wins 9 out of 10 times, and 10 out of 10 on neutral ground or in Iowa’s back yard.
I’m sick of teams getting hozed by the refs and in the opposing teams back yard. Why not play the games in Minneapolis or Detroit or Indianapolis? Is it that Florida is not tough enough to walk 10 minutes in 40 degree weather to the dome!?
Chris Spielman did a great job and was right on.
Comment by mark mikesell — January 3, 2006 @ 9:02 pm
11
Come on now, gents. Let’s cut Chris Leak a bit of slack.
How many of you have suffered 2 years of Ron Zook as your *gulp* coach?
You think that kind of abuse can be overcome in one season? This guy is lucky not to be self-admitted to a local padded cell with Nurse Ratchett hiking up his meds.
And volpundit: a ‘flower’ can be pretty tough … think snapdragons … even roses have thorns.
P.S. saying the offsides shouldn’t have been called is like saying my girlfriend is only a little bit pregnant.
P.P.S. saying the offsides shouldn’t have been called is like saying we’ll just ignore that pesky little shot clock at the end of the roundball game.
Comment by DHC — January 3, 2006 @ 5:05 pm